Upper-class people have trouble recognizing others' emotions

November 22, 2010

Upper-class people have more educational opportunities, greater financial security, and better job prospects than people from lower social classes, but that doesn't mean they're more skilled at everything. A new study published in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science, finds surprisingly, that lower-class people are better at reading the emotions of others.

The researchers were inspired by observing that, for lower-class people, success depends more on how much they can rely on other individuals. For example, if you can't afford to buy support services, such as daycare service for your children, you have to rely on your neighbors or relatives to watch the kids while you attend classes or run errands, says Michael W. Kraus of the University of California-San Francisco. He cowrote the study with Stéphane Côté of the University of Toronto and Dacher Keltner of the University of California-Berkeley.

One experiment used volunteers who worked at a university. Some had graduated from college and others had not; researchers used educational level as a proxy for . The volunteers did a test of emotion perception, in which they were instructed to look at pictures of faces and indicate which emotions each face was displaying. People with more education performed worse on the task than people with less education. In another study, university students who were of higher social standing (determined from each student's self-reported perceptions of his or her family's socioeconomic status) had a more difficult time accurately reading the emotions of a stranger during a group job interview.

These results suggest that people of upper-class status aren't very good at recognizing the emotions other people are feeling. The researchers speculate that this is because they can solve their problems, like the daycare example, without relying on others—they aren't as dependent on the people around them.

A final experiment found that, when people were made to feel that they were at a lower social class than they actually were, they got better at reading emotions. This shows that "it's not something ingrained in the individual," Kraus says. "It's the cultural context leading to these differences." He says this work helps show that stereotypes about the classes are wrong. "It's not that a lower-class person, no matter what, is going to be less intelligent than an upper-class person. It's all about the social context the person lives in, and the specific challenges the person faces. If you can shift the context even temporarily, social class differences in any number of behaviors can be eliminated."

Provided by Association for Psychological Science (news : web)

Filter


Move the slider to adjust rank threshold, so that you can hide some of the comments.


Display comments: newest first

jonnyboy
Nov 22, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (5)
researchers used educational level as a proxy for social class............NUFF SAID
MatthiasF
Nov 23, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (3)
So, the study finds that highly educated people care less about what others think (lack of emotional empathy).

Why is this news to anyone and why is it being projected onto the "upper-class"?
ArtflDgr
Nov 23, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
So women falsely will focus on lack of emotions as a sign of upper social status, which when wrong, is not a good thing
Skepticus
Nov 23, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (2)
With wealth and power comes privileges. Why should I care about what the foul-smelling rabbles feels when I can pass laws, change laws, buy votes, out-spend competitors, and sue almost anyone into the gutter?
And, by the way, I don't care if i make grammatical error here either.
marjon
Nov 23, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (3)
"for lower-class people, success depends more on how much they can rely on other individuals. For example, if you can't afford to buy support services, such as daycare service for your children, you have to rely on your neighbors or relatives to watch the kids while you attend classes or run errands,"
When the 'upper class' pay for child care, they are relying other others to care for their children, too.
In many cultures, children are cared for better with family, not strangers.
"...without relying on others—they aren't as dependent on the people around them."
Of course they are relying on others. They are just as dependent.
'this work helps show that stereotypes about the classes are wrong."
But the study did stereotype.(?)
le_mig
Nov 24, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
Many points - because much of what has been commented seems confused. It is just a brief news clip so over-simplicity is at fault, I think.

Class Proxy.
As stated, one experiment involved differing education levels (biased.) Another experiment was based on self-reported socioeconomic class levels (biased.) And the final experiment tried to lower the participants' sense of SEC to test the effect of that.

Education was used as a very loose proxy (not direct connection, but associative) to try to pin down and describe some of the effects of SEC without defeating the purpose by just using polled SEC reports carte blanche.
le_mig
Nov 24, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
You really can't just use annual income tax reports to evaluate differences in social interactions.

They weren't forced to use education (as they did in only 1 study) to weigh SEC.. they chose to use that as a controlled outside evaluation of class. The premise is rational and valid. It projects onto class because the trends of the education premise study matches those of their other SEC experiments.

Dependence vs Independence.
The stereotype they're testing is not the one about how best children are raised. The connection to education and class is aimed at, among others, financial security - as in whether or not differing classes are forced to rely heavily on their friends and family.. hence their attention to emotional perception!
le_mig
Nov 24, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
Being dependent on others for favors (while you spend time at work or .. wait for it .. Go to Class!) is very, very different than being independent enough to pay whomever you wish for childcare as you do whatever. Looking at this alone, you may not think education level is related.. but the other studies makes the emotional correlation to education as well.
le_mig
Nov 24, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (1)
Conclusion.
I see it like this. They're trying to pin down the chicken vs egg problem before others try to dismiss their findings as mere stereotypes about SEC. The findings make sense to me: Your emotional perception seems to increase the lower in class you FEEL, perhaps making you better able to find others to rely upon. This article is not demonizing the lack of emotion detection (and certainly is NOT calling upper-class less emotional or sociopathic either!!) It (very) simply points out how the ability to detect emotions seems to correlate with (and be changed by) how much one depends on her/his social connections.
le_mig
Nov 24, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
Because of the approach of these studies, you can't pin this one on just income or education alone. These findings along with a rationale from the "lower class" applies to both criteria suggesting that the types of financial/emotional security (and respective independence/ease of mind) often attributed to the "upper class" seems to lead all of us to use much less mental muscle - or at least in the departments of detecting the emotions of others.
Ravenrant
Nov 29, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
It's the plastic surgery and Botox, they aren't used to seeing emotions on peoples faces, the peasants are revolting.
Rank 4 /5 (22 votes)
Related Stories
Relevant PhysicsForums posts
  • stomach not emptying
    createdFeb 16, 2012
  • White reflections in photos in one eye
    createdFeb 15, 2012
  • Is Everyday Technology Killing Us?
    createdFeb 08, 2012
  • Exercise and weight loss
    createdFeb 08, 2012
  • Why do we have head aches? Our brains can't feel anything.
    createdFeb 07, 2012
  • "The end of diseases" by David Agus, interview from Daily Show with Jon Stewart
    createdFeb 04, 2012
  • More from Physics Forums - Medical Sciences

More news stories

CT colonography shown to be comparable to standard colonoscopy

Computerized tomographic (CT) colonography (CTC), also known as virtual colonoscopy, is comparable to standard colonoscopy in its ability to accurately detect cancer and precancerous polyps in people ages 65 and older, according ...

Medicine & Health / Cancer

created 2 hours ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0

Study: Virtual colonoscopy effective screening tool for adults over 65

Computed tomography (CT) colonography can be used as a primary screening tool for colorectal cancer in adults over the age of 65, according to a new study published online in the journal Radiology.

Medicine & Health / Other

created 2 hours ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0

What can animals' survival instincts tell us about understanding human emotion?

Can animals' survival instincts shed additional light on what we know about human emotion? New York University neuroscientist Joseph LeDoux poses this question in outlining a pioneering theory, drawn from two decades of research, ...

Medicine & Health / Neuroscience

created 13 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (3) | comments 4 | with audio podcast

Injectable gel could repair tissue damaged by heart attack

(Medical Xpress) -- University of California, San Diego researchers have developed a new injectable hydrogel that could be an effective and safe treatment for tissue damage caused by heart attacks.

Medicine & Health / Cardiology

created 17 hours ago | popularity 4.7 / 5 (6) | comments 3 | with audio podcast

Mini molecules could help fight battle of aortic bulge

When aortic walls buckle, the body's main blood pipe forms an ever-growing bulge. To thwart a deadly rupture, a team of Stanford University School of Medicine researchers has found two tiny molecules that may be able to orchestrate ...

Medicine & Health / Cardiology

created 12 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (1) | comments 0 | with audio podcast


Researchers build first physical 'metatronic' circuit

(PhysOrg.com) -- The technological world of the 21st century owes a tremendous amount to advances in electrical engineering, specifically, the ability to finely control the flow of electrical charges using ...

Spitzer finds solid buckyballs in space

(PhysOrg.com) -- Astronomers using data from NASA's Spitzer Space Telescope have, for the first time, discovered buckyballs in a solid form in space. Prior to this discovery, the microscopic carbon spheres ...

Faster than light neutrinos? More like faulty wiring

You can shelf your designs for a warp drive engine (for now) and put the DeLorean back in the garage; it turns out neutrinos may not have broken any cosmic speed limits after all.

Physicists surprised by disappearing and reappearing superconductivity in iron selenium chalcogenides

Superconductivity is a rare physical state in which matter is able to conduct electricity -- maintain a flow of electrons -- without any resistance. This phenomenon can only be found in certain materials at low temperatures, ...

Stanford research team cracks animated NuCaptcha

(PhysOrg.com) -- The research team from Stanford University, led by Elie Bursztein, that previously had cracked regular CAPTCHAs and then audio CAPTCHAs, now has also successfully cracked the animated version called NuCapt ...

Scientists create potent molecules aimed at treating muscular dystrophy

While RNA is an appealing drug target, small molecules that can actually affect its function have rarely been found. But now scientists from the Florida campus of The Scripps Research Institute have for the first time designed ...