Who should MDs let die in a pandemic? Report offers answers

May 5, 2008 By LINDSEY TANNER, AP Medical Writer

(AP) -- Doctors know some patients needing lifesaving care won't get it in a flu pandemic or other disaster. The gut-wrenching dilemma will be deciding who to let die.



Content from The Associated Press expires 15 days after original publication date. For more information about The Associated Press, please visit www.ap.org .

Similar stories from PHYSorg:

4.6 /5 (58 votes)  

Filter


Move the slider to adjust rank threshold, so that you can hide some of the comments.


Display comments: newest first

DGBEACH
May 05, 2008

Rank: 3.5 / 5 (2)
One thing's for sure; the lawyers will have a field day after one of these unforeseen disasters, and will have the nicest houses afterwards!
Arthur_Dent
May 05, 2008

Rank: 3 / 5 (1)
What about high-cost mental-patients?

Another question, if these humans are to be left without treatment, are they to be given pain-killers?

Or if not, are they to be permitted to die quickly, in *relative* freedom from suffering?
( that might require providing them with suicide pills, though they would obviously have to take the pills themselves, to make certain that the professionals weren't "killing" anyone )

Or are they simply to be stacked somewhere until they expire?

That /would/ cost the least, wouldn't it?

( no this isn't facetious: consider what has happened in the past, throughout this world's wars, particularly in ethnic-wars, and these sorts of questions must be asked, or they get answered in the maximal-suffering way, by default )
ChuckSmith
May 05, 2008

Rank: 3 / 5 (4)
This is where Universal Health Care goes in the end- if you don't meet certain criteria, you die. Tis policy is already in effect in Durham, NC. The EMS/ambulance crews have instructions from the hospital that if you are not within defined limits, they either do not transport, do not revive, do not providecare, or go slow with no lights. I found this out when I recertified on CPR.
mrlewish
May 05, 2008

Rank: 3 / 5 (2)
ChuckSmith stated "Universal Health Care goes in the end"
You've got to be kidding. This is where those without health insurance and insufficient health insurance are now.
Glis
May 05, 2008

Rank: 4.5 / 5 (2)
This title is misleading. It's not like they are going to say FU in a pandemic and NEVER help you, this is a way to prioritize patients, which makes sense when you've got millions needing care and hundreds able to provide. Naturally fellow doctors are at the top of the list, then able bodied/minded citizens, etc. You prioritize based on level of possible contribution. I would wager a diseased doctor would get care over a healthy 18yr old male if said doctor has a reasonable chance of recovering and helping in the crisis. The reason it's horrible to think about is because you are placing one person as 'move valuable' than another, but that potential value is crucial in situations like these.
gromit
May 05, 2008

Rank: 3.2 / 5 (6)
#1:ChuckSmith is not thinking with a fully functional brain, and will therefore be left to perish in the event of a pandemic.
#2:CPR certification (or re-certification) is not a survey course in triage nor could one consider themselves well versed in the shortcomings of a single-payer system after attending a 4 hour Red Cross class. Sorry.
#3:I can assure you that should such a disaster occur, those who need to will be VERY capable of determining who qualifies to receive care, and who should be de-prioritized for care allotment. While it is hard to imagine for most people in the U.S., this is something that occurs every day on a much smaller scale in the form of allocating OR time, ER beds, ventilators, etc. In other words, Physicians are 'practicing' for just such an event every day.
#4: This 'rationing' planning is needed due in large part to a paring down of vital resources and equipment by PRIVATE COMPANIES in order to streamline healthcare delivery. One cannot argue that we have a greater 'surge capacity' as a result of managed care. Trust me, whether our healthcare system is private or government run, in a pandemic, there will NEVER be enough 'stuff' for everyone, but given our current system, we are all gravely underequiped.
paanta
May 07, 2008

Rank: 3.3 / 5 (3)
Just to build on what Gromit said:

Triaging patients has been a key strategy in allocating limited resources since WWI. There's nothing at all shocking here.

At our major public research hospital/medical center (the largest in our region) for the hundred thousand people in the immediate area and the millions within an hour long drive from here, do you know how many beds we have? Well under a thousand. Do you know how many are ALREADY in use at any given time? 85% or more.

Each of those beds costs $1M to $2M to construct. Running a well equipped facility at 50% occupancy isn't an option for _any_ hospital, public or private, in any country, regardless of whether it's a single payer system or not.

This rationing would (will) be needed in any country, in any hospital. Yes, we've got surge capacity in an emergency, but it's simply impossible to equip yourself to treat everyone in a pandemic where >10% of the population needs to be in a million dollar hospital room.

Calling this a failure of the single-payer system is beyond ridiculous.
Fart49
May 07, 2008

Rank: 3.7 / 5 (3)
I recently attended a Emergency Management meeting sponsored by FEMA. Essentially, we were told that incarcerated persons, handicapped (menatlly challenged) and minorities are to receive priority care under FEMA guidelines in the aftermath of a serious emergency such as H5N1 pandemic, nuclear terrorism or other disaster. The reason is that these categories of persons are the most MEDIA SENSITIVE. What I learned is that our government bureaucrats are scared stiff that if they failed to treat prisoners, retarded persons and minorities, especially black people, their jobs will evaporate as a result of being piloried in the media. Consequently, if a minority and a white victim with identical injuries are encountered, the minority gets treated first. You don't believe me? I found it incredible too, yet that's what was telegraphed by our government officials.
TMA
May 08, 2008

Rank: 1 / 5 (2)
Revised list: 1. Felons currently serving time. 2. Felons who served time.
DeeSmith
May 08, 2008

Rank: not rated yet
Gromit has it rightly; the healthcare system will be so overwhelmed, hospitals and clinics will shut their doors and they will be guarded by police.

It won't matter what your ailment, you won't be treated past a certain stage of critical care demand (easily surpassed in a bad seasonal 'flu year).

Don't sweat the concept of treating incarcerated patients; you get a virus with the case fatality rate like SARS or H5N1, in crowded quarters with various viral diseases and a decided lack of vitamin D - trust me, it won't be an issue.

Mercury_01
May 12, 2008

Rank: not rated yet
I think the lesson here is that if something major were to happen, dont get hurt. Just covertly make your way to the canadian wilderness and trust that the mouth- breathers, wall martians, rich yuppies, assholes, chronically poor, and the like will be sufficiently weeded out one way or another.
Fart49
May 14, 2008

Rank: not rated yet
Actually, theree are FEMA policies that authorize euthenasia for older victims as well as other persons, other then "media sensitive" victims of terrorism, nuclear war etc. Agree that the issue of incarcerated persons, etc is moot in a pandemic as the close proximity of such persons will exacerbate to exppsure promblem for both inmates and guard staff. However, FEMA will prioritize assets for such persons and will in most cases treat the minority over the white in cases of injury, wounds etc. They are loath to the possiblility of media labeling them "racist," to the detriment of everyone else. Look at FEMA triage guidelines if you doubt this. FEMA is at core, a liberal organization and this was apparent at the number of regional meetings I've attended since 9/11.
xen_uno
May 14, 2008

Rank: not rated yet
I think politicians & lawyers should top the article's list. With a pandemic of truly global scale, they won't be needed ... or missed.
Rank 4.6 /5 (58 votes)
Tags

Relevant PhysicsForums posts

More news stories

US begins stem cell trial for hearing loss

US researchers have begun a groundbreaking trial to test the potential of umbilical cord blood transplants, a kind of stem cell therapy, to treat and possibly reverse hearing loss in infants.

Medicine & Health / Research

created 2 minutes ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0

New study: Adolescents suffering from depression more likely to be bullied

A new study provides evidence that adolescents who suffer from depression are more likely to develop difficulty in peer relationships including being bullied at school.

Medicine & Health / Psychology & Psychiatry

created 41 minutes ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0

Playing school sports affects youths' smoking

Young people's choices about using drugs and alcohol are influenced by peers—not only close friends, but also sports teammates. A new study of middle schoolers and their social networks has found that teammates' smoking ...

Medicine & Health / Health

created 43 minutes ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0

New procedure bests standard of care for fixing damaged cartilage

A new study has demonstrated that a procedure wherein healthy cartilage is transplanted to fix an area of damaged cartilage (osteoarticular cartilage transplantation or OATS procedure) is superior to the standard of care ...

Medicine & Health / Research

created 12 minutes ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0

Halting bone-building osteoporosis drug use cuts risk for additional atypical femur fracture in half

There is growing evidence that supports an association between atypical fractures of the femur– a rare break of the thigh bone, typically without trauma – and the use of bisphosphonates, drugs proven to enhance ...

Medicine & Health / Diseases

created 12 minutes ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0


Scared of a younger rival? Not for some male songbirds

When mature male white-crowned sparrows duel to win a mate or a nesting territory, a young bird just doesn't get much respect.

Tiny primate 'talks' in ultrasound

One of the world's smallest primates, the Philippine tarsier, communicates in a range of ultrasound inaudible to predator and prey alike, according to a study published on Wednesday.

Preventing bacteria from falling in with the wrong crowd could help stop gum disease

Stripping some mouth bacteria of their access key to gangs of other pathogenic oral bacteria could help prevent gum disease and tooth loss. The study, published in the journal Microbiology suggests that t ...

New study sheds light on genetics of rice metabolism

A large-scale study analyzing metabolic compounds in rice grains conducted by researchers at the RIKEN Plant Science Center (PSC) and their collaborators has identified 131 rice metabolites and clarified the ...

2.1 million viewers live stream Super Bowl online

(AP) -- The first live stream of the Super Bowl drew 2.1 million unique viewers, NBC said Thursday.

Ship noise boosts stress in whales, 9/11 reveals: study

The steady drone of motors along busy commercial shipping lanes not only alters whale behaviour but can affect the giant sea mammals physically by causing chronic stress, a study published Wednesday has reported ...