Team hopes to use new technology to search for ETs
June 4th, 2008
A Johns Hopkins astronomer is a member of a team briefing fellow scientists about plans to use new technology to take advantage of recent, promising ideas on where to search for possible extraterrestrial intelligence in our galaxy.
Richard Conn Henry, a professor in the Henry A. Rowland Department of Physics and Astronomy at Johns Hopkins' Zanvyl Krieger School of Arts and Sciences, is joining forces with Seth Shostak of the SETI Institute and Steven Kilston of the Henry Foundation Inc., a Silver Spring, Md., think tank, to search a swath of the sky known as the ecliptic plane. They propose to use new Allen Telescope Array, operated as a partnership between the SETI Institute in Mountain View, Calif., and the Radio Astronomy Laboratory at the University of California, Berkeley.
Comprising hundreds of specially produced small dishes that marry modern, miniaturized electronics and innovative technologies with computer processing, the ATA provides researchers with the capability to search for possible signals from technologically advanced civilizations elsewhere in our galaxy – if, in fact, such civilizations exist and are transmitting in this direction.
Employing this new equipment in a unique, targeted search for possible civilizations enhances the chances of finding one, in the same way that a search for a needle in a haystack is made easier if one knows at least approximately where the needle was dropped, said Henry, who is speaking about the proposal at the American Astronomical Society annual meeting in St. Louis.
According to the researchers, the critical place to look is in the ecliptic, a great circle around the sky that represents the plane of Earth's orbit. The sun, as viewed from Earth, appears annually to pass along this circle. Any civilization that lies within a fraction of a degree of the ecliptic could annually detect Earth passing in front of the sun. This ecliptic band comprises only about 3 percent of the sky.
"If those civilizations are out there – and we don't know that they are – those that inhabit star systems that lie close to the plane of the Earth's orbit around the sun will be the most motivated to send communications signals toward Earth," Henry said, "because those civilizations will surely have detected our annual transit across the face of the sun, telling them that Earth lies in a habitable zone, where liquid water is stable. Through spectroscopic analysis of our atmosphere, they will know that Earth likely bears life.
"Knowing where to look tremendously reduces the amount of radio telescope time we will need to conduct the search," he said.
Most of the 100 billion stars in our Milky Way galaxy are located in the galactic plane, forming another great circle around the sky. The two great circles intersect near Taurus and Sagittarius, two constellations opposite each other in the Earth's sky – areas where the search will initially concentrate.
"The crucial implication is that this targeted search in a favored part of the sky -- the ecliptic stripe, if you will – may provide us with significantly better prospects for detecting extraterrestrials than has any previous search effort," Kilston said.
Ray Villard of the Space Telescope Science Institute, who will join the team in its observations, said that in November 2001, STScI publicized Hubble Space Telescope observations of a transiting planet and "it occurred to me that alien civilizations along the ecliptic would likely be doing similar observations to Earth."
"Once they had determined Earth to be habitable, they might initiate sending signals," Villard said.
Shostak of SETI notes that the Allen Telescope Array is ideal for the team's plans to search the entire ecliptic over time, and not just the intersections of the ecliptic and galactic planes.
The team's presentation at the AAS meeting also explores possible scenarios for the appearance of civilizations in our galaxy.
"These models are nothing but pure speculation. But hey … it is educational to explore possibilities," Henry said. "We have no idea how many – if any – other civilizations there are in our galaxy. One critical factor is how long a civilization – for example, our own – remains in existence. If, as we dearly hope, the answer is many millions of years, then even if civilizations are fairly rare, those in our ecliptic plane will have learned of our existence. They will know that life exists on Earth and they will have the patience to beam easily detectable radio (or optical) signals in our direction, if necessary, for millions of years in the hope, now realized, that a technological civilization will appear on Earth."
Source: Johns Hopkins University
Jun 13, 2009 |
not rated yet |
0
I think the biggest problem with SETI is the time. If the civilization detected habitable earth, they might have been sending signals for couple of hundreds of years if that, then, the "contact earth" project was canned due to the budget cuts and they stopped broadcasting, and dinosaurs didn't have radio telescope to receive those signals.
JT
http://www.FireMe.To/udi
Just the fact it was detected at all would be enough to have pretty big consequences I think.
----
The alphabet is just a consequence of the fact I had nothing else to put up there, I could have just as easily made a bunch of random ascii symbols, but I assure you this message is a coded english sentence with no punctuation or spacing. Basicly you missed my point.
In the case of an alien signal, all you will get is binary, or some other number system used by a computer or transmitter. It will bear no resemblance whatsoever to any spoken or written earth language. If the aliens consider what I am talking about, they will only send a message that is related to mathematics or technology, because common words will not even have an equivalent. They will not have any of the animals we have, so their language will not translate to anything we are familliar with other than math or technology.
It isn't like translating english to spanish. In earth languages it basicly amounts to different words or phrases for the same meaning.
english -> spanish
cat = gato
dog = pero
hello = hola
english -> alien
cat = does not exist
dog = does not exist
hello = ???
What about getting the photos of the moon and mars that have obviously been airbrushed out de-classified and released. Then, if anything intelligently made becomes visible, we can try to contact them directly. Communication time will be seconds to minutes instead 10's of years.
"They may have already created spintronic computers and transmitters, and would be using different forms of modulation or quantum entanglement to communicate, in which case you couldn't intercept a message anyway. "
Here's the real point of this conversation. There is NO - I repeat: NO WHATSOEVER - indication that other technical civilizations that may be out there use radio waves for communication. It's a completely unjustified assumption, and very self-centric at that. I never really understood why almost every scientist would share this conviction, lending no critical thought to it. OK, let's say that at the dawn of SETI people didn't have enough imagination to even conceive different communication technologies, but today there is no excuse for that. What if those guys from Alpha-Centauri or Epsilon Eridani or wherever they may dwell, use neutrinos for telecom? What if they use quantum entanglement? What if hyperspace tech? What if their comms operate in superluminal modes, of which our science is not aware yet?
Also, suddenly, SETI people suggest that those other civilizations will surely use mass spectroscopy and maybe sth similar to Terrestrial Planet Finder to get info about our world. Wow, how did they figure it out? Why didn't they suggest the same, say, 20 years ago? Because we didn't HAVE that technology, nor BELIEVED it could be feasible then? Could that be the reason? Hmm...
Now, somehow I KNOW that when we develop superluminal communications, we will all of a sudden start assuming that this tech is so damn widely used across all the Universe. What a dramatically innovative thought...
Instead of wasting tons of money for ridiculous EM-based SETI explorations, they'd do a much better choice by focusing on inventing some really useful ways of long-distance communication, to which 30 light years is not an issue.
But then again, we all know such technologies are impossible, don't we?
This is such a ridiculous point of view, but it seems to turn up periodically. Why don't we look for superluminal or other signals? Because, as pointed out by neurogalactus, we don't HAVE that technology. So we should develop it right? Well, as it turns out, we are unable to develop technology for which there is NO underlying theory. Feel free to invent a neutrino or entanglement communication device yourself, but the rest of us will focus on more practical projects. Also, if we wanted to communicate with a more primitive intelligence -- say, monkeys -- I'm thinking we wouldn't rely on radio transmissions. So why would another intelligence send only signals that require advanced tech? Unless maybe they're not that intelligent. And please don't say that it might not be that advanced to them; entanglement/ neutrinos/hyperluminal anything requires more than basic tech, and certainly is more advanced than modulating light. Right?
And why should we wait to attempt this project until we have such technologies? People want to discover things before they die, and the wait might be a very long time indeed.
The arrogance of scientists who say "If those civilizations are out there...and we don't know that they are..." is astonishing. Its not a balanced argument as to whethere or not they exist; WE ARE the 'Existence Proof' that biological intelligence DOES exist in the cosmos. There is absolutely no reason to believe that we are alone, and never has been. This is like the old 'scientific' argument over whether or not water could be found elsewhere in the solar system, or whether or not other stars even had planets. Only fools ever doubted either, regardless of their credentials. Now that we have found more water even on tiny Jovian moons than exists on Earth, and planets around most every star we've looked at, perhaps it will give the skeptics pause when they attempt to deny the next incredibly obvious inevitability.