Study shows toll roads are more fair than taxes
August 20, 2008 By Stanley Paul(PhysOrg.com) -- Popular wisdom may suggest that toll roads are unfair to the poor, but a new joint study by UCLA and USC researchers shows that these pay-as-you-go transportation options may actually be fairer to all income levels than paying for road improvements through sales taxes.
"Just Pricing: The Distributional Effects of Congestion Pricing and Sales Taxes," examines the high-occupancy toll lanes on State Route 91 in Orange County, Calif., known as the 91 Express Lanes. The study is currently available in the online edition of the journal Transportation and comes "at a time when public officials in Los Angeles and other cities are considering congestion tolls and sales tax increases for transportation," according to study co-author Brain D. Taylor.
In the study, Taylor, professor and chair of urban planning at UCLA and director of the UCLA Institute of Transportation Studies, and co-author Lisa Schweitzer, assistant professor at USC's School of Policy, Planning, and Development, compared how two distinct transportation-funding mechanisms — a toll road and a tax measure — affect Orange County's lower-income residents.
Because many voters and elected officials oppose proposals for "congestion tolls" on equity grounds, road projects are usually funded by more politically acceptable sales taxes. The researchers found that this reasoning is flawed.
"Asking drivers to pay for road use ignites debates over fairness, but the debate often fails to address the larger question of how funding for transportation projects is actually being distributed throughout the community," Schweitzer said. "Freeways are a premium transport service, and they should be priced accordingly. The study shows that if we are prudent, we can do that while being sensitive to the circumstances of low-income drivers."
The 91 Express Lanes is a 10-mile stretch of roadway comprising four lanes in the center of the freeway reserved for registered users with transponders. Subscribers can choose to pay a toll to enter these lanes and bypass stop-and-go traffic in the adjacent "free" lanes. The tolls are set to keep traffic in the reserved lanes free-flowing and range from $1.25 to $10, depending on the direction and time of day.
The study found that the express lanes are disproportionately used by middle- and upper-middle-income households. Using this as a starting point, the researchers asked hypothetically how people of different income levels would be affected if the four express lanes had instead been financed with sales tax revenues.
To answer this question, they looked at Orange County's local option transportation sales tax, known as Measure M, which is levied on everyone who purchases taxable goods and services in the county. Measure M generated about $240 million annually during the period of the study, which considered expenditures by both Orange County residents and out-of-town visitors.
If Measure M funds had been used to finance the express lanes, the study found, the poor and wealthy would have paid more. Middle- and upper-middle-income taxpayers would have paid $26 million less each year than they paid under the current cost-distribution system, and the very poorest residents would have paid over $3 million more than they actually did under the current toll system.
Under the current 91 Express Lanes scenario, those who are paying the most to use the lanes are typically middle- and upper-middle-class households who have the freedom to decide whether the extra price is worth the savings in time.
"While regular users can pay dearly for the right to bypass 9 miles of bumper-to-bumper traffic — about $700 a year for heavy users and $300 a year for moderate users — all such payments are voluntary, because traveling in the congested free lanes is always an option," Taylor said.
The study notes that most forms of transportation finance — fuel taxes, sales taxes and tolls — are regressive forms of taxation in that they burden the poor more than the rich.
"Are tolls regressive? According to this and many previous analyses, yes. But for transport policy, whether tolls are regressive fails to fully address the justice and fairness issues that arise in financing road use," the researchers write. "Using sales taxes to fund roadways creates substantial savings to drivers by shifting some of the costs of driving from drivers to consumers at large, and in the process disproportionately favors the more affluent at the expense of the impoverished."
The researchers suggest that if policymakers are worried about low-income, peak-period commuters paying tolls, one way to address this would be to provide discounted "lifeline" pricing based on income levels, as is done by utility companies for qualifying customers, or provide travel credits to lower-income commuters. Another strategy is to use toll revenues to enhance transit services along the corridor so that people have an alternative to driving on the freeway.
While economists have long argued for "congestion tolls" on efficiency grounds, this groundbreaking new study suggests that such tolls may, surprisingly, increase equity in comparison to raising sales taxes to pay for transportation facilities.
The study is currently available online at http://www.springe … 327363227298 .
Provided by UCLA
-
What causes traffic gridlock?
Sep 07, 2011 |
4.2 / 5 (5) |
5
-
Germany outlines bold plan to drive electric
May 16, 2011 |
not rated yet |
1
-
Electric cars take off in Norway
May 10, 2011 |
5 / 5 (16) |
120
-
Honda's 'greenest' Civic to hit US showrooms
Apr 12, 2011 |
3.7 / 5 (3) |
6
-
Retailers shower shoppers with made-to-order ad campaigns
Jan 30, 2011 |
not rated yet |
1
-
Engineers build first sub-10-nm carbon nanotube transistor
Feb 01, 2012 |
5 / 5 (21) |
19
-
Something old, something new: Evolution and the structural divergence of duplicate genes
Jan 31, 2012 |
4.6 / 5 (7) |
1
-
The hidden nanoworld of ice crystals: Revealing the dynamic behavior of quasi-liquid layers
Jan 30, 2012 |
5 / 5 (2) |
1
-
Stock market network reveals investor clustering
Jan 27, 2012 |
4.1 / 5 (21) |
8
-
Of microchemistry and molecules: Electronic microfluidic device synthesizes biocompatible probes
Jan 26, 2012 |
not rated yet |
0
-
Best/Worst U.S. Presidents
Jan 31, 2012
-
The authencity of Joan of Arc
Jan 06, 2012
- More from Physics Forums - History & Humanities
More news stories
Unlike Patriots, NFL slow to embrace 'Moneyball'
(AP) -- It's advice that sounds like heresy on the gridiron: Go for it on fourth down. Try more onside kicks. Running backs don't matter much.
8 hours ago |
not rated yet |
0
Media portrayal of race in sports reveals biases in corporate world
The U.S. may have its first black president and the Fortune 500 its first black female chief executive, but African American CEOs account for a mere one percent of the chiefs of those 500 largest companies.
Other Sciences / Economics & Business
10 hours ago |
not rated yet |
0
Firms' own social networks better for business than Facebook
(PhysOrg.com) -- Using Facebook and Twitter may be good for a company's bottom line, but firms can rake in even bigger profits if they have their own virtual brand community, says a University of Michigan ...
Other Sciences / Economics & Business
14 hours ago |
1 / 5 (1) |
0
Marriage therapist says high-conflict couples have work to do before saying 'I do'
(PhysOrg.com) -- A Kansas State University marriage therapist has Valentine's Day advice for couples contemplating commitments and engagement rings: Mix romance with a generous portion of reality.
Other Sciences / Social Sciences
13 hours ago |
not rated yet |
0
Class size matters to those who struggle most
Research shows that class size does matter; and that it matters most for socio-economically disadvantaged learners, the very groups that the Government says it is most concerned about, says Massey University Professor of ...
Other Sciences / Social Sciences
14 hours ago |
5 / 5 (1) |
0
Whole exome sequencing identifies cause of metabolic disease
Sequencing a patient's entire genome to discover the source of his or her disease is not routine yet. But geneticists are getting close.
Amazon fungi found that eat polyurethane, even without oxygen
(PhysOrg.com) -- Until now polyurethane has been considered non-biodegradable, but a group of students from Yale University in the US has found fungi that will not only eat and digest it, they will do so even in the absence ...
Hearing metaphors activates brain regions involved in sensory experience
When a friend tells you she had a rough day, do you feel sandpaper under your fingers? The brain may be replaying sensory experiences to help understand common metaphors, new research suggests.
Scientists chart high-precision map of Milky Way's magnetic fields
(PhysOrg.com) -- Scientists at the Naval Research Laboratory (NRL) are part of an international team that has pooled their radio observations into a database, producing the highest precision map to date of ...
Discovery of extremely long-lived proteins may provide insight into cell aging
One of the big mysteries in biology is why cells age. Now scientists at the Salk Institute for Biological Studies report that they have discovered a weakness in a component of brain cells that may explain ...
Renowned physicist invents microscope that can peer at living brain cells
(PhysOrg.com) -- Ever since scientists began studying the brain, theyve wanted to get a better look at what was going on. Researchers have poked and prodded and looked at dead cells under electron microscopes, ...
Aug 20, 2008
Rank: 2.7 / 5 (7)
Aug 20, 2008
Rank: 3.8 / 5 (5)
Does this study even touch on the value that the roads of America provide to commerce?
Aug 20, 2008
Rank: 4.5 / 5 (4)
Aug 21, 2008
Rank: 3 / 5 (2)
They're only voluntary IF YOU CAN MAKE THEM. Else going around the toll road is the only option. Which makes them manifestly unfair to the poor ... without treatise-length argumentation.
On top of which, toll roads are a PITA. You either need to stop to pay or pay for more surveillance.
Those who are able to use the infrastructure to make a very comfortable living should recognize that option is not available to all. An income tax is an equitable, less PITA solution.
Aug 21, 2008
Rank: 5 / 5 (1)
Aug 21, 2008
Rank: 4 / 5 (2)
Aug 21, 2008
Rank: 2.5 / 5 (2)
Even better, this would end fuel taxes encouraging more alternatively fueled vehicles.
Aug 21, 2008
Rank: 3 / 5 (1)
see here:
Chicago - http://www.carand...d_column
http://www.carand...s_column
As far as I'm concerned, this breaks any amount of "fairness" on the issue of private toll roads.
Aug 21, 2008
Rank: 5 / 5 (1)
I had to respond to this message because you sir are wrong. There is a way for small family corporations to not have to pay taxes on the corporations. However, for big corporations like a factory the tax rate is the highest in the entire world at 35%. And people wonder why our jobs our being sent to China. Hmm maybe their corporate tax rate is half ours?
Aug 21, 2008
Rank: 2 / 5 (2)
The whole reason behind the Interstate system was NATIONAL SECURITY - to ensure good roads to move troops, supplies, and lastly, civilian populations, around in time of emergency or war. They were sold to the public by the less-scary idea of increased commerce, which is their function only when not needed in emergencies.
FREE HIGHWAYS are necessary to our national security! I would love to see a tank needing to go somewhere, only to have to knock over a toll booth first! And what if we are at odds with a country that owns our strategic roads? They could destroy the road and break our vital infrastructure to defend ourselves, or they could potentially establish those zones (many of which are 10 miles wide in effect) as actual bases within our sovereign territory - people live and work in those zones, and were IGNORED when these deals were made!
While this might not be the most likely scenario, it carries consequences so potentially severe - and occurring at a critical time - that it astonishes me that those in power would even consider this option...and makes me very suspicious of the reasons why they would even consider it.
We pay huge taxes already to support the road system here in Texas, taxes that are buried in everything, so they are impossible to calculate accurately, but probably are close to $1000 per year per driver. TxDOT (Texas Department of Transportation) has recently come under scrutiny for mismanagement and possibly corruption and illegal use of public funds while our roads, once the nicest in the US, are crumbling.
This is the same TxDOT that forced toll roads down our throats and added insult to injury by selling them to a Spanish company. Now they are converting highways paid for by taxes and already built into toll roads. Two of the affected roadways in the Austin area primarily serve poorer neighborhoods...and *will* cut them off because the road infrastructure here is an embarrassing example of letting real estate developers do the platting without overall planning or supervision, and the public transportation system is so bad that many people cannot make it to work on time no matter how early they leave in the morning...in other cases, it changes an 11-hour effective work day into 14 due to increased transit time...people with children can't deal with that! Tell me that such a consequence is not an unfair burden on the poor!
NO to ivory-tower academics pushing agendas! NO to foreign ownership of sovereign infrastructure! NO to politicians who sell us out! NO to toll roads! (And NO to PhysOrg.com toadying to the special interests!)
Aug 22, 2008
Rank: 3 / 5 (1)
VA is changing its policy for allowing hybrids with one driver in the car pool lane as that lane becomes filled.
Toll roads will be like the Fair Tax. I suggest a pilot program for people to volunteer to pay a toll for every road they travel using gps and/or cell phone technology to tally distance traveled. Fuel taxes would be refunded and tolls paid instead.