How to destroy an asteroid

December 3, 2008 Tara

Enlarge

"Tara," an asteroid being tracked by Tel Aviv University researchers. Credit: AFTAU

In the hit 1998 movie Armageddon, Bruce Willis and Ben Affleck blew up an asteroid to save the world. While the film was science fiction, the chances of an asteroid hitting the Earth one day are very real ― and blowing up an asteroid in real life, says a Tel Aviv University researcher, will be more complicated than in the movies.

Astrophysicists agree that the best method for avoiding a catastrophic collision would be to change the path of the asteroid heading toward our planet. "For that to work, we need to be able to predict what would happen if we attempt an explosion," says Tel Aviv University doctoral student David Polishook, who is studying asteroids with his supervisor Dr. Noah Brosch at the Department of Geophysics and Planetary Sciences.

Polishook and Brosch are among the few scientists in the world researching the structure and composition of asteroids –– a critical first step in learning how to destroy them before they reach the Earth's atmosphere. Their research could prevent catastrophe: blowing up an asteroid may create many equally dangerous smaller asteroids of about 100 meters each in diameter ― twice the size of the asteroid that created the famous Arizona crater.

Looking on the Bright Sides

"The information we are investigating can have a tremendous impact on future plans to alter the course of asteroids on a collision course with Earth," says Polishook. "Science needs to know whether asteroids are solid pieces of rock or piles of gravel, what forces are holding them together, and how they will break apart if bombed."

By observing the waxing and waning brightness of far-away asteroids, Polishook is able to examine the shape, spin period and surface composition of these flying rocks. "This is a good way of evaluating what asteroids are made of," says Polishook, who takes measurements on an almost daily basis at Tel Aviv University's Wise Observatory.

As part of their observations, the researchers used the fact that small asteroids change their rotation rate, accelerating or slowing down during short periods, as often as every 100,000 years. Compared to the age of the solar system – 4.5 billion years – that is an extremely fast change, says Polishook.

The most recent results of their research were presented at the 2008 meeting of Asteroids, Comets and Meteors, sponsored by the Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory in Baltimore.

Size Matters

An asteroid's rotation and acceleration are influenced by sunlight –– the "YORP Effect." If the YORP effect causes an asteroid to rotate faster than one revolution in 2.2 hours, it will break apart.

To understand how the YORP Effect works on asteroids, Tel Aviv University researchers examined several variables relating to these asteroids, including size and location. They concluded that size is the most important factor in determining how an asteroid's rotation rate accelerates according to the YORP Effect.

"We think this adds an important clue to how asteroids will behave should a space agency need to knock one off-course to prevent a collision with earth," Polishook notes.

Source: American Friends of Tel Aviv University


print this article email this article download pdf blog this article bookmark this article     Stumble it Digg this share on Facebook retweet share on Reddit add to delicious
Rate this story - 4.2 /5 (20 votes)

Rank Filter

Move the slider to adjust rank threshold, so that you can hide some of the comments.


Display comments: newest first

  • Doug_Loss - Dec 03, 2008
    • Rank: not rated yet
    I notice they mention the "flying gravel pile" conception of asteroid composition. If that's true, how could you possibly divert one? Pushing on it with rockets wouldn't work, and exploding anything near it would just give you a mildly wider gravel pile. You'd have to bag it and drag it somehow...
  • NeilFarbstein - Dec 03, 2008
    • Rank: 1 / 5 (1)
    Establish an asteroid buster force and build nuclear powered rockets that can get to an asteroid much quicker than chemical rockets. The VASIMIR ionic engine is closest to being operational. In tests it developed a hundredth the thrust of a regular rocket engine, beating other ionic engines by a longshot. NASA recently sold the patent license on VASIMIR to a private space company. This would cause a quantum leap in interplanetary space travel with rockets that can get to the asteroid belt in 6 weeks and to the asteroid belt in double that time. Besides protecting earth from an asteroid hit, asteroid mining might be economical decades ahead of schedule.
  • Doug_Huffman - Dec 03, 2008
    • Rank: not rated yet
    I don't know. Sure a gravel mountain bolide would be disastrous but that is a limit on a 2D continuum that should allow smearing the gravel mountain in space and time. Would a gravel drizzle be as catastrophic or a gravel downpour? What if the individual pieces were a bit larger?
  • TJ_alberta - Dec 04, 2008
    • Rank: 5 / 5 (1)
    I think what they may be hinting at is that one possibility of dealing with a loosely agglomerated asteroid would be to increase the spin to the point were centrifugal force would disperse it into components too small to survive atmospheric entry. Gravity will not be much, even for a large asteroid. If the "gravel" is held together with some kind of ice (not necessarily water ice) then perhaps decreasing the albedo will warm it >m.p. Solid asteroids would require a different approach.

    In any event, understanding the structure of tracked asteroids seems a worthwhile endeavor.
  • TJ_alberta - Dec 04, 2008
    • Rank: not rated yet
    just thought of something else. If you could warm up one corner of an asteroid, would any gas released achieve escape velocity and accelerate spin by reaction?
  • tkjtkj - Dec 04, 2008
    • Rank: not rated yet
    They concluded that size is the most important factor in determining how an asteroid's rotation rate accelerates according to the YORP Effect.
    "We think this adds an important clue to how asteroids will behave..."


    and do you care actually to share
    that 'behaviour' with us????

    This seems to be a 'non-article',
    so far as i can see.
  • DeadCorpse - Dec 04, 2008
    • Rank: not rated yet
    Interesting. Using the same principle that the radiometer works on to induce a spin in a agglomerated accretion body to create an inertial instability.

    Elegant. But who's gonna go up there and spray paint part of it black? Further, it'd take a few years for such a minuscule effect to induce sufficient spin in a mass the size of an Earth threatening asteroid. We're talking fractions of a Newton applied over large time scales to get them to spin as observed.

    A large area effect explosion would do two things: 1) Impart a rather violent force to the body. 2) If sufficient surface heat is generated, it could "blacken" the surface. If we are talking kilometers worth of asteroid, then we're talking nukes.

    Not sure the UN is gonna like that idea. Save the species or weaponize space.
  • FainAvis - Dec 04, 2008
    • Rank: not rated yet
    Spin it up by whatever means but keep a large mass tethered by a cable. When the spin is high enough cut the cable and the two masses fly off in different directions.
  • Thecis - Dec 08, 2008
    • Rank: not rated yet
    To create spin, a new concept could also be used, namely a mirror...
    Set up a giant mirror on earth, catch sunlight, reflect it and make sure the focus is right on the asteroid itself. This induces melting as the change of water of vapor makes it is acting as a small rocket, "pushing" the asteroid out of its trajectory.
    A few notes.
    1. How to make sure the focus is correct? You'll see
    2. Will this be enough for larger asteroids? I haven't got a clue. Some astronomers will know, because this is an idea that has been announced before.
    3. What to do if it comes from outside the solar system, from the dark side of the earth... Well, other options are welcome as well ;-)

December 3, 2008 all stories

Comments: 9

4.2 /5 (20 votes)
  • Stumble this up

  • Digg this

  • share this

  • hide
  • Related Stories

  • We owe it all to comets
    created Apr 28, 2009 | popularity not rated yet | comments 0
  • NASA's Wise Gets Ready to Survey the Whole Sky (w/ Video)
    created Nov 17, 2009 | popularity not rated yet | comments 0
  • Unusual meteorite found by time-lapse camera observatory
    created Nov 05, 2009 | popularity not rated yet | comments 0
  • Panel says NASA should skip moon, fly elsewhere (Update)
    created Oct 23, 2009 | popularity not rated yet | comments 0
  • Study of first high-resolution images of Pallas confirms asteroid is actually a protoplanet
    created Oct 12, 2009 | popularity not rated yet | comments 0



  • hide
  • Relevant PhysicsForums posts

  • Are there green, purple and pink stars?
    created 7 hours ago
  • Sideral question
    created Nov 21, 2009
  • Doppler shifted blackbody spectrum
    created Nov 21, 2009
  • Earth v. Moon
    created Nov 21, 2009
  • More from Physics Forums - General Astronomy

Other News

The shore of Deception Island in Antarctica, in 2008

Antarctic ice loss vaster, faster than thought: study

Space & Earth / Earth Sciences

created 11 hours ago | popularity 2.6 / 5 (12) | comments 10

The East Antarctic icesheet, once seen as largely unaffected by global warming, has lost billions of tonnes of ice since 2006 and could boost sea levels in the future, according to a new study.


Denmark: 65 world leaders for UN climate summit (AP)

Denmark: 65 world leaders for UN climate summit

Space & Earth / Environment

created 11 hours ago | popularity 1 / 5 (2) | comments 2

(AP) -- Sixty-five world leaders have said they will attend the Copenhagen climate summit in December, and several more have responded positively to invitations, Danish officials said Sunday.


Astronaut's baby daughter born as he circles Earth (AP)

Astronaut's baby daughter born as he circles Earth

Space & Earth / Space Exploration

created 11 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (1) | comments 0

(AP) -- Astronaut Randolph Bresnik jubilantly welcomed his new daughter into the world Sunday as he floated 220 miles above it.


Commuters wait on the platform shrouded by fog in London

Climate change not man-made, say majority of Britons: poll

Space & Earth / Environment

created Nov 15, 2009 | popularity 3.4 / 5 (16) | comments 46

Less than half of Britons believes that human activity is to blame for global warming, according to a poll carried out for The Times newspaper and published on Saturday.


Mysteriously warm times in Antarctica

Mysteriously warm times in Antarctica

Space & Earth / Earth Sciences

created Nov 18, 2009 | popularity 4.2 / 5 (21) | comments 31

(PhysOrg.com) -- A new study of Antarctica's past climate reveals that temperatures during the warm periods between ice ages (interglacials) may have been higher than previously thought. The latest analysis ...