Rethinking Brownian motion with the 'Emperor's New Clothes'

July 27, 2009

In the classic fairy tale, "The Emperor's New Clothes," Hans Christian Andersen uses the eyes of a child to challenge conventional wisdom and help others to see more clearly. In similar fashion, researchers at the University of Illinois have now revealed the naked truth about a classic bell-shaped curve used to describe the motion of a liquid as it diffuses through another material.

"The new findings raise fundamental questions concerning the statistical nature of the diffusion process," says Steve Granick, Founder Professor of Engineering, and professor of materials science and engineering, of chemistry, of chemical and biomolecular engineering, and of physics at the U. of I.

Diffusion is critical to processes such as drug delivery, water purification, and the normal operation of living cells. Key to the diffusion process is the manner in which the motion of one molecule affects the motion of another.

"In high school science classes, students are often assigned the task of using a microscope to watch a particle of dust sitting in a drop of water," Granick said. "The dust particle seems alive, moving back and forth, never in the same way. The motion of the dust particle is caused by the random 'kicks' of surrounding ."

Called "Brownian motion" (after botanist Robert Brown, who noticed it in 1828), this phenomenon of fluids was described by in 1905, when he published his statistical molecular theory of liquids.

According to Einstein, if the motions of many particles were watched, and the distance each moved in a certain time were recorded, the distribution would resemble the familiar Gaussian, bell-shaped curve used to assign grades in a science class.

Einstein had it right - almost.

"Like Einstein, we used to think we could describe Brownian motion with a standard bell-shaped curve," Granick said. "But now, with the ability to measure very small distances much more precisely than was possible 100 years ago, we have found that we can have extremes much farther than previously imagined."

In a paper to be published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences Online Early Edition next week, the U. of I. researchers show that Einstein's explanation, commonly cited in textbooks, fails in certain important cases.

The experiments were conducted by precisely tracking the motion of 100-nanometer colloidal beads using fluorescence microscopy.

In one series of experiments, the researchers watched as the beads moved up and down tiny tubes of lipid molecules by Brownian motion. In a second series of experiments, the researchers watched as the beads diffused through a porous membrane of entangled macromolecule filaments, again by Brownian motion.

In both sets of experiments, there were many features in full agreement with Einstein and the bell-shaped curve; but there were also features in significant disagreement. In those cases, the beads moved much farther than the common curve could predict. In those extreme displacements, diffusion behavior was not Gaussian, the researchers report. The behavior was exponential.

"These large displacements happen less often, but when they do occur, they are much bigger than we previously thought possible," Granick said.

The new findings "change the rules of the diffusion game," Granick said. "Like the emperor's new clothes, now that we know the bell-shaped curve isn't always the right way to think about a particular problem, process, or operation, we can begin to design around it, and maybe take advantage of it. And, we can correct the textbooks."

Source: University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (news : web)

4.7 /5 (19 votes)  

Filter


Move the slider to adjust rank threshold, so that you can hide some of the comments.


Display comments: newest first

Slotin
Jul 28, 2009

Rank: 3.7 / 5 (3)
Why we should correct our textbooks?

Mr. Einstein has derived diffusion for bulk medium. If he asked him to derive it for porous medium, then his equations would be different. Diffusion through porous medium is just a special case of diffusion and original equations still remain valid.

Should we rewrite Navier-Stokes equations in textbooks just because liquid flows through capillars in laminar way only?
Zygo
Jul 28, 2009

Rank: not rated yet
The other aspect of Brownian Motion that Einstein observed was the mean distance a particle moved( in straightline from its starting point) is proportional to the square root of the time interval that had elapsed. For example if the particle moves at 1 m/sec then after 4 seconds it has moved 2 metres, after 9 seconds 3 metres etc
AtomThick
Jul 28, 2009

Rank: 2.5 / 5 (2)
Using statistics you can't guess the exact position or velocity of a dust particle on the surface of the water, but you can guess how 100 particles will move on average. The fact that some particles are off the chart that doesn't mean the chart is bad it just means the term "statistics" was missunderstood by those scientists.
omatumr
Jul 28, 2009

Rank: 1 / 5 (3)
DIFFUSION IS INDEED IMPORTANT

Congratulations!

For several years we struggled with observations that clearly showed evidence of severe mass fractionation of isotopes and elements from diffusion in meteorites, in planets, in the solar wind, and in solar flares.

For example the elements that Donald V. Reames observed in a solar flare with the Wind spacecraft [Ap. J. 540 (2000) L111%u2013L114] http://epact2.gsf...0HiZ.pdf

Mass fractionated neon in meteorites was mistakenly labeled as Ne-A, Ne-B, Ne-C, Ne-D, Ne-E, Ne-A1, Ne-A2, Ne-E(l), Ne-E(h), Ne-O from 1967-1980 ["The Neon Alphabet Game" in Proceedings of the 11th Lunar Planet Sci. Conf. 15, Number 2 (1980) 879-899] http://tinyurl.com/n5r24t

Recently it was finally realized that the Sun itself operates a plasma diffuser, selectively moving lightweight elements - like H and He - and lightweight isotopes of each element to its surface.

With kind regards,
Oliver K. Manuel
http://www.omatumr.com
Ant
Jul 28, 2009

Rank: 1 / 5 (2)
There are far more interesting topics related to particle vibration and brownian motion than the mathamatics of any stupid curve bell shaped or otherwise. Observation and interpritation is the requirement not stupid maths
RayCherry
Jul 28, 2009

Rank: not rated yet
Slotin: At each reprint of a text book, each topic should be updated to reflect new knowledge that could alter the validity of the original. There is no point in miseducating the next generation - they will not thank us for it, as we do not thank our teachers for the amount of old knowledge we have had to revise or dispense with.
wsbriggs
Jul 28, 2009

Rank: not rated yet
It shouldn't surprise anyone that in the small, Brownian motion is a subset of a scaling distribution. This is our old friend, the Levy Distribution, with exponents making it look like a Gaussian Distribution, or a close approximation.

Remember, Wall Street thought that Mandelbrot was insane when he suggested that fractal Brownian motion described the movements of markets better. We know better now, don't we.
E_L_Earnhardt
Jul 28, 2009

Rank: 1 / 5 (2)
Over-due experiments include the movements of energy-active electrons through the membrane covering of a living cell to accelerate mitosis and result in the malfunction called "CANCER"!
Slotin
Jul 28, 2009

Rank: 1 / 5 (1)
..here is no point in miseducating the next generation..
It's the point of scientific journalism, which is fighting for public attention and grant money support.
nebulous
Jul 29, 2009

Rank: not rated yet
Is any thought given to the possible effect of observation with regard to any Brownian motion testing?
Rank 4.7 /5 (19 votes)
Related Stories
Relevant PhysicsForums posts
  • Physical laws .... are they material?!!
    created44 minutes ago
  • increasing time of daylight
    created1 hour ago
  • Light & Sight
    created1 hour ago
  • Wind Turbine Power
    created4 hours ago
  • Steam Table issues
    created6 hours ago
  • electrostatic induction in a conductor should be immpossible
    created10 hours ago
  • More from Physics Forums - General Physics

More news stories

Hovering not hard if you're top-heavy, researchers find

Top-heavy structures are more likely to maintain their balance while hovering in the air than are those that bear a lower center of gravity, researchers at New York University's Courant Institute of Mathematical Sciences ...

Physics / General Physics

created 1 hour ago | popularity 5 / 5 (1) | comments 1 | with audio podcast

SLAC, Stanford team focuses on high-energy electrons to treat cancer

Accelerator physicists at SLAC and cancer specialists from Stanford are working on a new technology that could dramatically reduce the time needed for cancer radiation treatments. The team ran an initial experiment ...

Physics / General Physics

created 4 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (1) | comments 0

Measurements from high-energy collisions lead to better understanding of why meson particles disappear

For several years, physicists at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) at Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL), USA, have studied an unusual state of matter called the quark–gluon plasma, which they ...

Physics / General Physics

created 4 hours ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0

Quantum physicist explains $100K offer for proof scaled-up quantum computing is impossible

(PhysOrg.com) -- MIT researcher Scott Aaronson has certainly riled the physics community with his offer this past Friday, of $100,000 to anyone who can prove that scaled-up quantum computing is impossible. ...

Physics / Quantum Physics

created Feb 08, 2012 | popularity 4.1 / 5 (11) | comments 32 | with audio podcast weblog

Explained: Sigma

It's a question that arises with virtually every major new finding in science or medicine: What makes a result reliable enough to be taken seriously? The answer has to do with statistical significance -- but ...

Physics / General Physics

created Feb 09, 2012 | popularity 5 / 5 (14) | comments 34


Grass to gas: Researchers' genome map speeds biofuel development

Researchers at the University of Georgia have taken a major step in the ongoing effort to find sources of cleaner, renewable energy by mapping the genomes of two originator cells of Miscanthus x giganteus, a large perenn ...

Researchers develop new method for creating tissue engineering scaffolds

Researchers at Northwestern University have developed a new method for creating scaffolds for tissue engineering applications, providing an alternative that is more flexible and less time-intensive than current technology.

Molecular profiling reveals differences between primary and recurrent ovarian cancers

There is a need to analyze tumor specimens at the time of ovarian cancer recurrence, according to a new study published in Molecular Cancer Therapeutics. Researchers used a diagnostic technology called molecular profiling to examine ...

C-sections linked to breathing problems in preterm infants

Research conducted at Yale School of Medicine shows that a cesarean (C-section) delivery, which was thought to be harmless, is associated with breathing problems in preterm babies who are small for gestational age.

Review: Netflix and Hulu's new scripted originals

Within just over a week, Netflix and Hulu are both debuting their first stabs at original scripted programming.

India probes Google over 'forex transactions'

Indian authorities are probing whether online giant Google broke domestic foreign-exchange transactions rules while shifting funds abroad, the Press Trust of India reported on Friday.