Aesop's fable 'the crow and the pitcher' more fact than fiction (w/ Video)

August 6, 2009

In Aesop's fable 'The crow and the pitcher' a thirsty crow uses stones to raise the level of water in a pitcher to quench its thirst. A new study published online today (06 August) in the journal Current Biology demonstrates that rooks, birds belonging to the corvid (or crow) family, are able to solve complex problems using tools and can easily master the same technique demonstrated in Aesop's fable.

Christopher Bird of the University of Cambridge, lead author of the paper, highlighted the importance of the findings, stating: "Corvids are remarkably intelligent, and in many ways rival the great apes in their physical intelligence and ability to solve problems. The only other animal known to complete a similar task is the orang-utan.

"This is remarkable considering their brain is so different to the great apes'. Although it has been speculated in folklore, empirical tests are needed to examine the extent of their intelligence and how they solve problems."

FLV player

The video shows the first trial in which Connelly is required to raise the water level by a varying amount. In this trial seven stones are needed to raise the water level and worm to the "reachable height." Connelly flies to the testing platform and investigates the apparatus before the stones are added. Connelly adds seven stones before successfully acquiring the worm. He then leaves the testing platform.

FLV player

The video shows the second trial in which Connelly is required to raise the water level by a varying amount. In this trial only one stone is needed to raise the water level and worm to the "reachable height." Connelly flies to the testing platform and investigates the apparatus before the stones are added. Connelly adds one stone before successfully acquiring the worm. He then leaves the testing platform.

In the first part of the study, at which point the researchers varied the height of the water, the four rooks which were the subject of the research used stones to raise the water level to reach a worm floating on top. The clever birds proved very adept and were highly successful regardless of the starting level of the water and the number of the stones needed.

Two of the birds were successful on their first try to raise the height of the water to a level at which the worm floating on top could be reached whilst the other two birds needed a second try.

The birds were also highly accurate in their ability, adding the exact number of stones needed to raise the water level to the necessary height. Additionally, rather than attempting to reach the worm after each stone was dropped, they apparently estimated the number needed from the outset and waited until the appropriate water level was reached before dipping their beaks into the tube.

FLV player

The video shows Monroe selectively choosing to use larger stones rather than smaller ones. Monroe flies to the testing platform and investigates the apparatus before the stones are added. Monroe adds three large stones before successfully acquiring the worm. She then leaves the testing platform.

FLV player

The video shows Cook selectively dropping stones into the tube containing water rather than the tube containing sawdust. Cook flies to the testing platform and investigates both tubes before the stones are added. Cook adds four large stones to the water before successfully acquiring the worm. He then leaves the testing platform

In the second experiment the rooks were presented with stones which varied in size. The rooks selected larger stones over smaller ones (although not straight away). The scientists speculate that the birds learnt rapidly that the larger stones displaced more water and they were therefore able to obtain the reward more quickly than using small stones.

In the third experiment, the rooks were observed to recognise that sawdust could not be manipulated in the same manner as water. Therefore when presented with the choice between a tube half-filled with either sawdust or water, rooks dropped the pebbles into the tube containing water and not the sawdust.

Although the study demonstrates the flexible nature of tool use in rooks, they are not believed to use tools in the wild.

"Wild tool use appears to be dependent on motivation," Bird said. "Rooks do not use tools in the wild because they do not need to, not because they can't. They have access to other food that can be acquired without using tools."

As Bird noted, that fits nicely with Aesop's maxim, demonstrated by the crow: "Necessity is the mother of invention."

More information: The paper 'Rooks Use Stones to Raise the Water Level to Reach a Floating Worm' will be published on the Current Biology website.

Source: University of Cambridge (news : web)

• OregonWind - Aug 06, 2009
  • Rank: 2 / 5 (1)
  This is remarkable!
  
  Actually, I think the crow raised the water level to be able to reach and eat an insect (?) that was floating on the surface.
  • report abuse
  • • Current rank
    • 1
    • 2
    • 3
    • 4
    • 5
• fsmith - Aug 06, 2009
  • Rank: 3.5 / 5 (2)
  Yes, we've known how to do this for some time now. Do you want us to explain how it works? Do you want us to write your thesis for you too?
  
  
  /rook
  • report abuse
  • • Current rank
    • 1
    • 2
    • 3
    • 4
    • 5
• RobertKLR - Aug 06, 2009
  • Rank: 3 / 5 (2)
  So that's how you get the worm. For years I just passed them by.
  • report abuse
  • • Current rank
    • 1
    • 2
    • 3
    • 4
    • 5
• undrgrndgirl - Aug 07, 2009
  • Rank: 4.5 / 5 (2)
  not surprised...most fables and myths are built on truth...the researcher's name is BIRD! lol!
  • report abuse
  • • Current rank
    • 1
    • 2
    • 3
    • 4
    • 5
• Alexa - Aug 10, 2009
  • Rank: 1 / 5 (1)
  Well, if we consider, scientists cannot recognize, vacuum is dense matter for two thousands of years, then the crows aren't bad at all in recognizing of connections of observable world.
  • report abuse
  • • Current rank
    • 1
    • 2
    • 3
    • 4
    • 5