U.S. Chamber of Commerce pushes for 'Scopes Monkey Trial' of global warming science
August 25, 2009 By Jim TankersleyThe nation's largest business lobby wants to put the science of global warming on trial. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce, trying to ward off potentially sweeping federal emissions regulations, is pushing the Environmental Protection Agency to hold a rare public hearing on the scientific evidence of man-made climate change.
Chamber officials say it would be "the Scopes Monkey Trial of the 21st century" -- complete with witnesses, cross-examinations and a judge who would rule, essentially, on whether humans are warming the planet to dangerous effect.
"It would be evolution versus creationism," said William Kovacs, the chamber's senior vice president for environment, technology and regulatory affairs. "It would be the science of climate change on trial."
But the EPA is having none of it, calling such a hearing a "waste of time" and saying a threatened lawsuit by the chamber if the request is denied would be "frivolous." EPA spokesman Brendan Gilfillan said the agency based its proposed finding that global warming is a danger to public health "on the soundest peer-reviewed science available, which overwhelmingly indicates that climate change presents a threat to human health and welfare."
The goal of the chamber, which represents 3 million large and small businesses, is to ward off potentially sweeping federal emissions regulations by undercutting the scientific consensus over climate change. If the EPA denies the request, as expected, the chamber plans to take the fight to federal court.
Environmentalists say the strategy is an attempt to sow political discord by challenging settled science -- and note that in the famed 1925 Scopes Trial, which pitted lawyers Clarence Darrow and William Jennings Bryan in a courtroom battle over a Tennessee science teacher accused of teaching evolution illegally, the scientists won.
The chamber proposal "brings to mind for me the Salem witch trials, based on myth," said Brenda Ekwurzel, a climate scientist for the environmental group Union of Concerned Scientists. "In this case, it would be ignoring decades of publicly accessible evidence."
In the coming weeks, the EPA is set to formally declare that the heat-trapping gases scientists blame for climate change endanger human health and are thus subject to regulation under the Clean Air Act. The so-called "endangerment finding" will be a cornerstone of the Obama administration's plan to set strict new emissions standards on cars and trucks.
The proposed finding has drawn more than 300,000 public comments. Many of them question scientists' projections that rising temperatures will lead to increased mortality rates, harmful pollution and extreme weather events such as hurricanes.
In light of those comments, the chamber will tell the EPA in a filing on Tuesday that a trial-style public hearing -- which is allowed under the law, but nearly unprecedented on this scale -- is the only way to "make a fully informed, transparent decision with scientific integrity based on the actual record of the science."
Most climate scientists agree that greenhouse gas emissions, caused by the burning of fossil fuels and other human activities, are warming the Earth. Using computer models and historical temperature data, those scientists predict the warming will accelerate unless humankind dramatically reduces its greenhouse emissions.
"The need for urgent action to address climate change is now indisputable," the heads of the top science agencies at 13 of the world's largest countries, including the head of the U.S. National Academy of Sciences, wrote in a letter to world leaders last month.
The EPA's endangerment finding for greenhouse gases, as proposed in April, warned that warmer temperatures would lead to "the increased likelihood of more frequent and intense heat waves, more wildfires, degraded air quality, more heavy downpours and flooding, increased drought, greater sea level rise, more intense storms, harm to water resources, harm to agriculture, and harm to wildlife and ecosystems."
Critics of the finding say it's far from certain that warming will cause any harm at all. The Chamber of Commerce cites studies that predict higher temperatures will reduce mortality rates in the United States.
___
(c) 2009, Chicago Tribune.
Visit the Chicago Tribune on the Internet at http://www.chicagotribune.com/
Distributed by McClatchy-Tribune Information Services.
-
EPA finds greenhouse gases pose a danger to health
Apr 17, 2009 |
not rated yet |
0
-
EPA closer to global warming warning (Update)
Mar 23, 2009 |
not rated yet |
0
-
EPA releases report on climate change and health
Jul 17, 2008 |
not rated yet |
0
-
Ethanol test for Obama on climate change, science
May 03, 2009 |
not rated yet |
0
-
Report: Human activity fuels global warming
Feb 02, 2007 |
not rated yet |
0
-
Engineers build first sub-10-nm carbon nanotube transistor
Feb 01, 2012 |
4.9 / 5 (31) |
30
-
Something old, something new: Evolution and the structural divergence of duplicate genes
Jan 31, 2012 |
4.6 / 5 (7) |
1
-
The hidden nanoworld of ice crystals: Revealing the dynamic behavior of quasi-liquid layers
Jan 30, 2012 |
5 / 5 (3) |
1
-
Stock market network reveals investor clustering
Jan 27, 2012 |
3.9 / 5 (23) |
8
-
Of microchemistry and molecules: Electronic microfluidic device synthesizes biocompatible probes
Jan 26, 2012 |
5 / 5 (1) |
0
-
Discrepancy between oxygen and carbon-dioxide levels
19 hours ago
-
where gems are found in the world
22 hours ago
-
Wind Waves in Reservoir ~ Wind run-up and Wind set-up
Feb 08, 2012
-
Balance of oxygen in the atmosphere
Feb 01, 2012
-
The case for a methanol-based economy
Jan 30, 2012
-
Weather in a rotating cylinder
Jan 25, 2012
- More from Physics Forums - Earth
More news stories
Humans may have helped the decline of African rainforests 3000 years ago
(PhysOrg.com) -- Large areas of rainforests in Central Africa mysteriously disappeared over three thousand years ago, to be replaced by savannas. The prevailing theory has been that the cause was a change ...
Could Venus be shifting gear?
(PhysOrg.com) -- ESAs Venus Express spacecraft has discovered that our cloud-covered neighbour spins a little slower than previously measured. Peering through the dense atmosphere in the infrared, the ...
Space & Earth / Space Exploration
7 hours ago |
5 / 5 (5) |
7
|
Mars Science Laboratory computer issue resolved
(PhysOrg.com) -- Engineers have found the root cause of a computer reset that occurred two months ago on NASA's Mars Science Laboratory and have determined how to correct it.
Space & Earth / Space Exploration
8 hours ago |
5 / 5 (5) |
3
|
Clam fields found at deep, low-temperature Mariana vents
(PhysOrg.com) -- Scientists have marveled at the unusual life forms thriving at high temperature hydrothermal vents of the deep ocean.
Space & Earth / Earth Sciences
7 hours ago |
not rated yet |
0
|
Two new moons for Jupiter
Advances in technology have lead to the discovery of new planets outside of our Solar System, and now even new moons in our own backyard.
Space & Earth / Space Exploration
7 hours ago |
not rated yet |
5
Complex wiring of the nervous system may rely on a just a handful of genes and proteins
Researchers at the Salk Institute have discovered a startling feature of early brain development that helps to explain how complex neuron wiring patterns are programmed using just a handful of critical genes. ...
CIA website offline, Anonymous takes credit
The website of the Central Intelligence Agency was unresponsive on Friday after the hacker group Anonymous claimed to have knocked it offline.
Q&A: Obama and the birth control controversy
(AP) -- What birth control debate? A half-century after the introduction of the pill, acceptance of birth control by American women is virtually universal.
The power of estrogen -- male snakes attract other males
A new study has shown that boosting the estrogen levels of male garter snakes causes them to secrete the same pheromones that females use to attract suitors, and turned the males into just about the sexiest ...
New error-correcting codes guarantee the fastest possible rate of data transmission
Error-correcting codes are one of the triumphs of the digital age. Theyre a way of encoding information so that it can be transmitted across a communication channel such as an optical fiber o ...
Both maternal and paternal age linked to autism
Older maternal and paternal age are jointly associated with having a child with autism, according to a recently published study led by researchers at The University of Texas Health Science Center at Houston (UTHealth).
Aug 26, 2009
Rank: 2.6 / 5 (5)
Aug 26, 2009
Rank: 3 / 5 (6)
It is not about pollution. CO2 is not a pollutant, despite the EPA declaring it a pollutant. It is essential for life as we know it.
The inestimable cost which will be exacted from the U.S. population by this purely political decision is unconscionable.
Aug 26, 2009
Rank: 3 / 5 (6)
Aug 26, 2009
Rank: 1 / 5 (1)
How do you figure that cost exactly? Is it the nuclear reactors and solar thermal ($0.035 / kwh if we'd get on the stick now) generation? Is it the electric vehicles and railways substiuting for depleting, costly imported oil? Please provide numbers with references.
Aug 26, 2009
Rank: 3.7 / 5 (3)
This would put the issue to rest until further information becomes available. This would reveal the evidence, sans emotionalized propaganda.
I hate to say it, but we need this, however, it has to be done in a neutral and unbiased manner.
Aug 26, 2009
Rank: 1.5 / 5 (4)
It's furthermore beyond ignorant to believe a need for something like this exists when the evidence has already been weighed many times before on a far grander scale by far better judges.
Aug 26, 2009
Rank: 4 / 5 (1)
Get a clue my friend. Every single individual who consumes from our economic system is just as much if not more to blame than business, because they control what they consume. Take responsibility for your life, don't pawn it off on those who facilitate it.
I fear it wouldn't create any consensus, or put anything to rest, and it will almost certainly not be unbiased.
Aug 26, 2009
Rank: 5 / 5 (1)
As for your comment brian, does that mean that class action lawsuits don't work since only 1 lawyer shows up for each side? Use a real argument, not the usual garbage.
Aug 27, 2009
Rank: 1 / 5 (1)
"It is not about pollution. CO2 is not a pollutant, despite the EPA declaring it a pollutant. It is essential for life as we know it."
Nothing is a pollutant in and of itself. A chemical's toxicity is relative to the environment that it is placed in and highly dependent upon the quantity of that element. For instance, to anaerobic bacteria, oxygen is a toxin, while to us it is essential to our well-being. Aspirin in light doses is a helpful medicine for people, in large doses it is poisonous. It is not the chemical composition that determines something a "pollutant" but the way that chemical functions in the system which it is placed in. And whether or not that functioning is disturbed is dependent upon the purpose or teleology that that system is perceived to be driven toward. Nothing is innately a pollutant. It just must be proven to harmful disrupt the functioning of the system it is placed in.
Aug 27, 2009
Rank: 5 / 5 (1)
Remember who won and who lost that trial. Ignorance won and Scopes lost. So I don't think its a good precedence.
Ethelred
Sorry for the new signature. But It Needed Killun.
From QubitTamer's fake profile
Qubitwit gets the rest of August in my signature for aiming his idiocy at me. Again.
Aug 29, 2009
Rank: 5 / 5 (1)
Aug 29, 2009
Rank: 1 / 5 (2)
Your question begs another question:
1. Why does anyone want to limit CO2 in the atmosphere?
(The answer, of course, is money, power and redistribution of wealth.)
Aug 29, 2009
Rank: 1 / 5 (2)
You're cute aren't you? Class-action lawsuits are different because they do not revolve around the expert scientific testimony of large numbers of those people represented. In that case the large numbers of people involved are the victims only. Even if it worked out in the courtroom and the truth won, I can tell you that the the public would see the open forum differently, much more balanced than it is in the real world.
Aug 30, 2009
Rank: 3 / 5 (2)
Aug 31, 2009
Rank: not rated yet
No.
Correct, which is intriguing since the Sun is a lower temperature than normal and the world should have a lower temperature instead of the same temperature. If the Sun continues that way then that will be good. If goes back to normal then the temperatures will rise.
Ethelred
Sorry for the new signature. But It Needed Killun.
From QubitTamer's fake profile
Qubitwit gets the rest of August in my signature for aiming his idiocy at me. Again.
Sep 04, 2009
Rank: not rated yet
So none of the pharmacological lawsuits involved expert testimony of a scientific nature?
Jackass.