New CO2 data helps unlock the secrets of Antarctic formation

September 13, 2009
Antarctic

Enlarge

Credit: Ted Scambos, University of Colorado, NSIDC

The link between declining CO2 levels in the earth's atmosphere and the formation of the Antarctic ice caps some 34 million years ago has been confirmed for the first time in a major research study.

A team of scientists from Cardiff, Bristol and Texas A&M universities braved the lions and hyenas of a small East African village to extract microfossils in samples of rocks which show the level of CO2 in the Earth's at the time of the formation of the ice-cap.

Geologists have long speculated that the formation of the ice-cap was caused by a gradually diminishing natural greenhouse effect.

The study's findings, published in Nature online, confirm that atmospheric CO2 declined during the Eocene - Oligocene climate transition and that the Antarctic began to form when CO2 in the atmosphere reached a tipping point of around 760 parts per million (by volume).

Professor Paul Pearson from Cardiff University's School of Earth and Ocean Sciences, who led the mission to the remote East Africa village of Stakishari said: "About 34 million years ago the Earth experienced a mysterious cooling trend. Glaciers and small ice sheets developed in Antarctica, sea levels fell and temperate forests began to displace tropical-type vegetation in many areas.

"The period, known to geologists as the Eocene - Oligocene transition, culminated in the rapid development of a continental-scale ice sheet on Antarctica, which has been there ever since.

"We therefore set out to establish whether there was a substantial decline in atmospheric carbon dioxide levels as the Antarctic ice sheet began to grow."

The team mapped large expanses of bush and wilderness and pieced together the underlying local rock formations using occasional outcrops of rocks and stream beds.

Eventually they discovered sediments of the right age near a traditional African village called Stakishari. By assembling a drilling rig and extracting hundreds of meters of samples from under the ground they were able to obtain exactly the piece of Earth's history they had been searching for.

Co-author Dr Gavin Foster from the University of Bristol Earth Sciences Department said: "By using the rather unique set of samples from Tanzania and a new analytical technique that I developed, we have, for the first time, been able to reconstruct the concentration of CO2 across the Eocene-Oligocene boundary - the time period about 34 million years ago when ice sheets first started to grow on Eastern Antarctica. "

The new findings offer important lessons for the future and will add to the debate around rising CO2 levels in the earth's atmosphere as the world's attention turns to on UN Climate Conference, which opens in Copenhagen later this year.

Co-author Dr Bridget Wade from Texas A&M University Department of Geology and Geophysics added: "This was the biggest climate switch since the extinction of the dinosaurs 65 million years ago.

"Our study is the first to provide a direct link between the establishment of an sheet on Antarctica and atmospheric carbon dioxide levels and therefore confirms the relationship between levels in the atmosphere and global climate."

Source: Cardiff University (news : web)

4.1 /5 (15 votes)  

Filter


Move the slider to adjust rank threshold, so that you can hide some of the comments.


Display comments: newest first

dachpyarvile
Sep 14, 2009

Rank: 1 / 5 (4)
Excellent article! I find this interesting:
The study's findings, published in Nature online, confirm that atmospheric CO2 declined during the Eocene - Oligocene climate transition and that the Antarctic ice sheet began to form when CO2 in the atmosphere reached a tipping point of around 760 parts per million (by volume).


Conversely, since the ice cap formed in Antarctica as a result of the tipping point of 760 ppm CO2, we should have no fear of a catastrophic melt of the Antarctic ice cap in our own day.

This is especially so when our CO2 level is well below that tipping point and at a level of less than 385 ppm!

We would nearly have to double our current average global CO2 level to reach the tipping point again--if the science is right, that is. And, the tipping point is where the ice cap began to form.

The new findings offer important lessons for the future and will add to the debate...


You aren't kidding!
Torbjorn_Larsson_OM
Sep 14, 2009

Rank: 3.3 / 5 (3)


Conversely, since the ice cap formed in Antarctica as a result of the tipping point of 760 ppm CO2, we should have no fear of a catastrophic melt of the Antarctic ice cap in our own day.

That doesn't follow at all. Since catasthropic tipping points most often are associated with hysteresis, we're more or less assured that whatever the tipping point is, it isn't exactly the above data. I.e. such systems have hysteresis. (Not always, but much more likely.)

That observation would also, if we forget about hysteresis for a moment, be the end of the ice-cap. Not the start of it's melting, which is already observed.

The next likely tipping point for Antarctica is IIRC that the western ice cap melts, not the whole of it. The western ice cap differs from the east, it is subjected to sea water. This will push the needed CO2 forcing way down. And that event would be bad, as it would drown huge areas of land and islands.
Torbjorn_Larsson_OM
Sep 14, 2009

Rank: 4 / 5 (4)
Sorry about the bad HTML format of the intended quote.

[cont.]

Now there are mechanisms that push back the disappearance of the last remnants of the ice cap. The likely hysteresis is one.

Another is the missing piece of information in that article: plates have changed considerably over 34 million years.

"India started to collide with Asia beginning about 35 Ma, forming the Himalayan orogeny, and also finally closing the Tethys Seaway; this collision continues today. The African Plate started to change directions, from west to northwest toward Europe, and South America began to move in a northward direction, separating it from Antarctica and allowing complete oceanic circulation around Antarctica for the first time, causing a rapid cooling of the continent and allowing glaciers to form. [Wikipedia: "Pangaea"; my bold.]"
Torbjorn_Larsson_OM
Sep 14, 2009

Rank: 2.5 / 5 (2)
[cont.]

If the above is correct, and without having looked at the actual research, it is nevertheless IMHO doubtful that the measured CO2 forcing was primarily responsible for Antarctica ice caps. It might instead be a consequence of indirect forcing from plate tectonics, as the plants on for example Antarctica disappeared.

If so (and add likely hysteresis to this) it could mean that a considerable higher CO2 forcing is needed to remove the ice cap fully. This observation would then be a lower bound on an upper bound estimate. I might be mistaken, but such a construct doesn't seem to add much information on a system. (As opposed to, say, an upper bound on an upper bound estimate.)
Velanarris
Sep 14, 2009

Rank: 3.6 / 5 (5)
Anyone notice that they didn't establish any sort of causative in the paper?

They ASSUMED the two are related by one driving the other, yet they did not establish that there was any other mechanism that could be responsible for both.

If the Sun dropped in brightness for any reason, or even more likely some sort of global dimming occured the resultant reduction in energy received by the planet would cool the oceans. Cooling oceans provide a massive Co2 sink. This could be wholly correlative and not causative with the Eocene-Oglicene separation of Patagonia and Antartica which is the mechanism that keeps the Antartic so dry.

There's too much background noise to give this creedence in any manner beyond it being a hypothesis with possible retro-predicative results.

Can these same conclusions be drawn against other periods in time with similar data sets?
dachpyarvile
Sep 14, 2009

Rank: 2.8 / 5 (5)
Part of the problem is that other factors are not taken into account. For example, one side of the Antarctic still appears stable whereas the other side is showing some degree of melt. We do know that there is an active volcano on the side that is melting, which volcano last blew a hole through the Antarctic ice c. 325 CE.

Nonetheless, I cannot see evidence for a catastrophic melt of any kind coming from Antarctica any time soon, as the predictions claim.
Rank 4.1 /5 (15 votes)
Relevant PhysicsForums posts
  • Discrepancy between oxygen and carbon-dioxide levels
    created14 hours ago
  • where gems are found in the world
    created18 hours ago
  • Wind Waves in Reservoir ~ Wind run-up and Wind set-up
    createdFeb 08, 2012
  • Balance of oxygen in the atmosphere
    createdFeb 01, 2012
  • The case for a methanol-based economy
    createdJan 30, 2012
  • Weather in a rotating cylinder
    createdJan 25, 2012
  • More from Physics Forums - Earth

More news stories

Could Venus be shifting gear?

(PhysOrg.com) -- ESA’s Venus Express spacecraft has discovered that our cloud-covered neighbour spins a little slower than previously measured. Peering through the dense atmosphere in the infrared, the ...

Space & Earth / Space Exploration

created 3 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (4) | comments 4 | with audio podcast

Humans may have helped the decline of African rainforests 3000 years ago

(PhysOrg.com) -- Large areas of rainforests in Central Africa mysteriously disappeared over three thousand years ago, to be replaced by savannas. The prevailing theory has been that the cause was a change ...

Space & Earth / Environment

created 7 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (3) | comments 8 | with audio podcast report

Clam fields found at deep, low-temperature Mariana vents

(PhysOrg.com) -- Scientists have marveled at the unusual life forms thriving at high temperature hydrothermal vents of the deep ocean.

Space & Earth / Earth Sciences

created 4 hours ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0 | with audio podcast

Mars Science Laboratory computer issue resolved

(PhysOrg.com) -- Engineers have found the root cause of a computer reset that occurred two months ago on NASA's Mars Science Laboratory and have determined how to correct it.

Space & Earth / Space Exploration

created 4 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (5) | comments 2 | with audio podcast

Two new moons for Jupiter

Advances in technology have lead to the discovery of new planets outside of our Solar System, and now even new moons in our own backyard.

Space & Earth / Space Exploration

created 3 hours ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 2


New understanding of DNA repair could eventually lead to cancer therapy

A research group in the Faculty of Medicine & Dentistry at the University of Alberta is hoping its latest discovery could one day be used to develop new therapies that target certain types of cancers.

Hovering not hard if you're top-heavy, researchers find

Top-heavy structures are more likely to maintain their balance while hovering in the air than are those that bear a lower center of gravity, researchers at New York University's Courant Institute of Mathematical Sciences ...

Grass to gas: Researchers' genome map speeds biofuel development

Researchers at the University of Georgia have taken a major step in the ongoing effort to find sources of cleaner, renewable energy by mapping the genomes of two originator cells of Miscanthus x giganteus, a large perenn ...

Night, weekend delivery OK for babies with birth defects

Weekday delivery is no better than night or weekend delivery for infants with birth defects, according to a new study presented today at The Pregnancy Meeting, the Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine's annual conference. ...

Sonic Cradle lands spot in TED exhibition

A Simon Fraser University graduate student project that melds music, meditation and modern technology has landed a rare spot as an exhibit at TEDActive 2012 in Palm Springs, California this month.

Drug halts organ damage in inflammatory genetic disorder

A new study shows that Kineret (anakinra), a medication approved for the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis, is effective in stopping the progression of organ damage in people with neonatal-onset multisystem inflammatory disease ...