'Hitler' skull belonged to woman: scientists

September 29, 2009 by Jane Mills

A skull fragment thought to come from Adolf Hitler is in fact that of an unidentified woman, according to a US study that has resurrected questions about the Nazi leader's death.

The bone, bearing a bullet hole, has been held up to support the theory that Hitler shot himself and took cyanide in his Berlin bunker as Soviet troops approached in April 1945.

Doubts about the chain of events -- and even speculation that Hitler got away -- have persisted for decades.

The debates made the symbolic importance of the piece, which went on display for the first time at Moscow's Federal Archive in 2000, all the greater -- a unique war trophy which gave the Russians enormous pride.

In addition to the skull, Soviet troops said they exhumed Hitler's jawbone and that the bone's identity was confirmed through his dental assistants.

Now, professors at the University of Connecticut say they have debunked the story of the skull, arguing that examinations show it belonged to a woman, probably between the age of 20 and 40.

Archeologist and bone specialist Nick Bellantoni says he immediately suspected the bone belonged to a woman because of its structure.

His partner on the project, Professor Linda Strausbaugh, director of the university's applied genetics center, agreed to test for DNA if a good sample could be found.

So Bellantoni made the trip to Moscow, where he was allowed to obtain the DNA sample, and at the end of May the team got to work in the university's laboratory in Storrs, Connecticut.

It took them three days, working with two forensic scientists from the office of the New York City chief medical examiner, to complete their tests.

Initially they feared the state of the skull would make it impossible to obtain results.

"All we had exposure to was photographs. What was exposed to us was the side that was charred. Fire is one of the real enemies of getting out," Strausbaugh told AFP.

The skull had been stored at room temperature which had also damaged the DNA. However, the inside of the fragment was not burned and "the amounts we had were well within the range that you would expect to get DNA samples from," she said.

The result was stunning.

"What the DNA told us is that it was female," Strausbaugh said.

The revelation is featured in a new documentary airing on the History Channel called "Hitler's Escape," which revisits the idea that Hitler may have escaped from Berlin.

But Strausbaugh says her testing proves nothing about Hitler's fate -- only that the skull purported to be his belonged to someone else.

Holocaust historian Christopher Browning, a professor at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, said that the results of tests on the skull would not change the consensus that Hitler died in the bunker.

Historians do not rely solely on accounts by Soviet troops, he said. They also have investigations from the period, including one by British intelligence officers who collected corroborating evidence from witnesses about the corpses of Hitler and Eva Braun.

"None of it is depending on the alleged validity of a body or skull in Russian possession," Browning said. "When the History Channel says this throws in doubt everything we've known since 1945, that's false."

The Soviets reported digging up and moving several times remains thought to be those of Hitler, Braun or propaganda minister Joseph Goebbels and his wife and children, Brown said.

"From the point of view of archival integrity, (the skull) has no standing whatsoever," he said.

In fact, some Russian officials and scientists have also expressed doubts about the skull fragment.

Strausbaugh said the historical value of the bone and other pieces of physical evidence collected by the Soviets was undermined by sloppy procedures.

"The problem with many of these samples is they haven't been archived, they haven't been stored properly," she said.

If additional DNA samples from family members of those who died in the bunker could be obtained, the relics might tell their story.

But for now, the identity of the skull in the Moscow archives is set to remain an enigma, Strausbaugh said.

(c) 2009 AFP


   
Rate this story - 3.7 /5 (7 votes)

Rank Filter

Move the slider to adjust rank threshold, so that you can hide some of the comments.


Display comments: newest first

  • SincerelyTwo - Sep 29, 2009
    • Rank: not rated yet
    It's a shame that the fact is essentially irrelevant, and it sounds like everybody is choosing to ignore the lack of significance of this find. But I guess in times of economic hardship anything to draw viewers and make money will be perpetuated.

    It was clearly determined at the time, as they explicitly state by multiple investigations, that he is in fact dead. Unless people think the worlds powers worked together in obscuring his death ... then the conspiracy nuts will go on about it for all time not realizing they're never going to get the answer they want. So even IF by some long measure he is alive, it'll never be verified and there's nothing to be had about it all anyway.
  • Otto1882 - Sep 29, 2009
    • Rank: not rated yet
    Hitler would of died of natural causes anyway many decades ago, he was already in poor health in the 40's, so there is no chance he is alive as he would be way over a 100 years old.
  • Arikin - Sep 29, 2009
    • Rank: not rated yet
    Of course the collection procedures were sloppy. You are talking about soldiers trying to stop a war. Just proves trophies are all mental with a perchance physical reminder.

    At the time who was thinking "Maybe we should freeze this for future DNA sampling"? Besides, like SincerelyTwo and Otto1882 mentioned above, the man is dead either way.
  • docknowledge - Sep 30, 2009
    • Rank: not rated yet
    Consider the source of the skull. Stalinist Russia. In this situation, the conspiracy nuts wouldn't have a difficult time making some sort of case.

September 29, 2009 all stories

Comments: 4

3.7 /5 (7 votes)

  • hide
  • Related Stories

  • Is Indy chasing a fake?
    created May 23, 2008 | popularity not rated yet | comments 0
  • Researchers confirm lead as cause of Beethoven's illness
    created Dec 06, 2005 | popularity not rated yet | comments 0
  • 700-year-old murder discovered
    created Jan 24, 2006 | popularity not rated yet | comments 0
  • Museum unveils world's largest T-rex skull
    created Apr 07, 2006 | popularity not rated yet | comments 0
  • Smallest Triceratops skull described
    created Mar 06, 2006 | popularity not rated yet | comments 0



  • hide
  • Relevant PhysicsForums posts

  • Sleeping habits and the risk of cancer
    created Feb 08, 2010
  • Pressure in chambers of the heart
    created Feb 07, 2010
  • Primordial soup canned?
    created Feb 07, 2010
  • Where on the r/K selection theory scale do social insects like ants and bees fall?
    created Feb 06, 2010
  • Testosterone levels and Fighting
    created Feb 05, 2010
  • Evolution Simulator
    created Feb 04, 2010
  • More from Physics Forums - Biology

Other News

Study challenges bird-from-dinosaur theory of evolution - was it the other way around?

Study challenges bird-from-dinosaur theory of evolution - was it the other way around?

Other Sciences / Archaeology & Fossils

created 9 hours ago | popularity 4.1 / 5 (9) | comments 4 | with audio podcast

(PhysOrg.com) -- A new study just published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences provides yet more evidence that birds did not descend from ground-dwelling theropod dinosaurs, experts say, a ...


'Counterfactual' thinkers are more motivated and analytical, study suggests

Other Sciences / Social Sciences

created 13 hours ago | popularity 4.4 / 5 (5) | comments 5 | with audio podcast

(PhysOrg.com) -- "If only I had..." Almost everyone has said those four words at some time. Rather than intensifying regret, '"what if" reflection about pivotal moments in the past helps people to weave a coherent life story, ...


The Glass Cliff: Female representation in politics and business

Other Sciences / Social Sciences

created 4 hours ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0

Leadership positions in business have proven to be precarious for women. Female business leaders are more likely to be appointed to powerful leadership positions when an organization is in crisis or high-risk circumstances. ...


Office romance? Not a problem most of time: study

Office romance? Not a problem most of time: study

Other Sciences / Social Sciences

created 11 hours ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 1

(PhysOrg.com) -- Pam and Jim on The Office. Meredith and McDreamy on Grey's Anatomy. Television shows depict many workplace romances, but in the real world how do co-workers view love on the job? According ...


Women on board: Does forced diversity hurt firm performance?

Other Sciences / Social Sciences

created 11 hours ago | popularity 1 / 5 (1) | comments 1

(PhysOrg.com) -- New SEC rules will require public firms to disclose what role, if any, diversity plays in appointing members to their corporate boards, but University of Michigan researchers say any forced restructuring ...