Scientists Develop New Method to Quantify Climate Modeling Uncertainty

October 21, 2009

(PhysOrg.com) -- Climate scientists recognize that climate modeling projections include a significant level of uncertainty. A team of researchers using computing facilities at Oak Ridge National Laboratory has identified a new method for quantifying this uncertainty.

The new approach suggests that the range of uncertainty in projections may be greater than previously assumed. One consequence is the possibility of greater warming and more later in the century under the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change's (IPCC) high fossil fuel use scenario.

The team performed an ensemble of computer "runs" using one of the most comprehensive climate models--the Community Climate System Model version 3, developed by the National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR)--on each of three IPCC scenarios. The first IPCC scenario, known as A1F1, assumes high global economic growth and continued heavy reliance on fossil fuels for the remainder of the century. The second scenario, known as B1, assumes a major move away from fossil fuels toward alternative and renewable energy as the century progresses. The third scenario, known as A2, is a middling scenario, with less even economic growth and some adoption of alternative and renewable energy sources as the century unfolds.

The team computed uncertainty by comparing model outcomes with historical from the period 2000-2007. Models run on historical periods typically depart from the actual recorded for those time spans. The team used statistical methods to develop a range of temperature variance for each of the three scenarios, based on their departure from actual historical data.

The approach's outcome is roughly similar to the National Weather Service's computer predictions of a hurricane's path, familiar to TV viewers. There is typically a dark line on the weather map showing the hurricane's predicted path over the next few days, and there is a gray or colored area to either side of the line showing how the hurricane may diverge from the predicted path, within a certain level of probability. The ORNL team developed a similar range of variance--technically known as "error bars"--for each of the scenarios.

Using resources at ORNL's Leadership Computing Facility, the team then performed ensemble runs on three decade-long periods at the beginning, middle, and end of the twenty-first century (2000-2009, 2045-2055, and 2090-2099) to get a sense of how the scenarios would unfold over the twenty-first century's hundred years.

Interestingly, when the variance or "error bars" are taken into account, there is no statistically significant difference between the projected temperatures resulting from the high fossil fuel A1F1 scenario and the middling A2 scenario up through 2050. That is, the A1F1 and A2 error bars overlap. After 2050, however, the A1F1 range of temperature projections rise above those of A2, until they begin to overlap again toward the century's end.

Typically climate scientists have understood the range of uncertainty in projections to be the variance between high and low scenarios. But when the error bars are added in the range between high and low possibilities actually widens, indicating greater uncertainty.

"We found that the uncertainties obtained when we compare model simulations with observations are significantly larger than what the ensemble bounds would appear to suggest," said ORNL's Auroop R. Ganguly, the study's lead author.

In addition, the error bars in the A1F1 scenario suggests at least the possibility of even higher temperatures and more heat waves after 2050, if fossil fuel use is not curtailed.

The team also looked at regional effects and found large geographical variability under the various scenarios. The findings reinforce the IPCC's call for greater focus on regional climate studies in an effort to understand specific impacts and develop strategies for mitigation of and adaptation to climate change.

The study was published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Co-authors include Marcia Branstetter, John Drake, David Erickson, Esther Parish, Nagendra Singh, and Karsten Steinhaeuser of ORNL, and Lawrence Buja of NCAR. Funding for the work was provided by ORNL's new cross-cutting initiative called Understanding Climate Change Impacts through the Laboratory Directed Research and Development program.

More information: The paper can be accessed electronically here: http://www.pnas.or … 106/37/15555

Provided by ORNL

4.1 /5 (9 votes)  

Filter


Move the slider to adjust rank threshold, so that you can hide some of the comments.


Display comments: newest first

GrayMouser
Oct 21, 2009

Rank: 2 / 5 (4)
The new approach suggests that the range of uncertainty in climate projections may be greater than previously assumed.

ASSUMED??? These people have been proposing multi-trillion dollar projects based on an assumed uncertainty?
What happened to "the science is settled"?
axemaster
Oct 22, 2009

Rank: 4.2 / 5 (5)
This actually isn't such a big deal. Any scientist worth his (or her) salt would be aware that these error bars were there, they just weren't sure how to calculate exactly how large they were. So this isn't really much of a change.

And just for the record, no credible scientist has at any point said that they believe they can predict exactly what will happen. All they can say for sure is that temperatures will go up within a certain range, and so far they've been correct. Don't criticize them for political reasons.
mikiwud
Oct 22, 2009

Rank: 1 / 5 (4)
And just for the record, no credible scientist has at any point said that they believe they can predict exactly what will happen. All they can say for sure is that temperatures will go up within a certain range, and so far they've been correct. Don't criticize them for political reasons.


WHAT!? your are joking? correct? CORRECT? who? when? If the goal posts are far enough appart, someone will eventually score.
3432682
Oct 22, 2009

Rank: 1 / 5 (4)
Yeah, the science is settled. It settles more each year, like ancient ruins.
Yellowdart
Oct 22, 2009

Rank: 1 / 5 (3)
So they extrapolated based on 7 years worth of data? And all their projections still overlap? So curtailing economic growth and fossil fuel use to renewable seems to have little effect overall?

Thanks.
defunctdiety
Oct 22, 2009

Rank: 1 / 5 (4)
...when the variance or "error bars" are taken into account, there is no statistically significant difference between the projected temperatures resulting from the high fossil fuel A1F1 scenario and the middling A2 scenario...

AGW proponents, please think hard about this, and how it relates to the need for the proposed economically damaging regulations.

The truth is coming out. Academic honesty will prevail. And so long as the People are able to reclaim control of their government, so to will the People prevail.
Rank 4.1 /5 (9 votes)
Relevant PhysicsForums posts
  • Discrepancy between oxygen and carbon-dioxide levels
    createdFeb 09, 2012
  • where gems are found in the world
    createdFeb 09, 2012
  • Wind Waves in Reservoir ~ Wind run-up and Wind set-up
    createdFeb 08, 2012
  • Balance of oxygen in the atmosphere
    createdFeb 01, 2012
  • The case for a methanol-based economy
    createdJan 30, 2012
  • Weather in a rotating cylinder
    createdJan 25, 2012
  • More from Physics Forums - Earth

More news stories

Humans may have helped the decline of African rainforests 3000 years ago

(PhysOrg.com) -- Large areas of rainforests in Central Africa mysteriously disappeared over three thousand years ago, to be replaced by savannas. The prevailing theory has been that the cause was a change ...

Space & Earth / Environment

created 18 hours ago | popularity 4.2 / 5 (10) | comments 12 | with audio podcast report

Could Venus be shifting gear?

(PhysOrg.com) -- ESA’s Venus Express spacecraft has discovered that our cloud-covered neighbour spins a little slower than previously measured. Peering through the dense atmosphere in the infrared, the ...

Space & Earth / Space Exploration

created 14 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (7) | comments 7 | with audio podcast

NASA budget will axe Mars deal with Europe: scientists

US President Barack Obama's budget proposal to be submitted next week for 2013 will cut NASA's budget by 20 percent and eliminate a major partnership with Europe on Mars exploration, scientists said Thursday.

Space & Earth / Space Exploration

created 17 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (2) | comments 18

Mars Science Laboratory computer issue resolved

(PhysOrg.com) -- Engineers have found the root cause of a computer reset that occurred two months ago on NASA's Mars Science Laboratory and have determined how to correct it.

Space & Earth / Space Exploration

created 15 hours ago | popularity 4.7 / 5 (6) | comments 3 | with audio podcast

Two new moons for Jupiter

Advances in technology have lead to the discovery of new planets outside of our Solar System, and now even new moons in our own backyard.

Space & Earth / Space Exploration

created 14 hours ago | popularity 4 / 5 (1) | comments 7


Anonymous knocks CIA website offline (Update)

The website of the Central Intelligence Agency was inaccessible on Friday after the hacker group Anonymous claimed to have knocked it offline.

Google users warned of threat to smartphone wallets

Users of Google smartphone wallets were being warned on Friday that there is a way to crack pass codes intended to thwart thieves from going on illicit shopping sprees.

New error-correcting codes guarantee the fastest possible rate of data transmission

Error-correcting codes are one of the triumphs of the digital age. They’re a way of encoding information so that it can be transmitted across a communication channel — such as an optical fiber o ...

Complex wiring of the nervous system may rely on a just a handful of genes and proteins

Researchers at the Salk Institute have discovered a startling feature of early brain development that helps to explain how complex neuron wiring patterns are programmed using just a handful of critical genes. ...

The power of estrogen -- male snakes attract other males

A new study has shown that boosting the estrogen levels of male garter snakes causes them to secrete the same pheromones that females use to attract suitors, and turned the males into just about the sexiest ...

New power source discovered

(PhysOrg.com) -- Researchers at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) and RMIT University have made a breakthrough in energy storage and power generation.