Evidence 'steadily mounting' for cosmic life

February 3, 2010

Evidence is 'steadily mounting' that life on Earth began elsewhere in the Universe and was brought here by comets, according to a new paper by Professor Chandra Wickramasinghe.

Professor Wickramasinghe, Director of the Cardiff Centre for Astrobiology, says that a clear pronouncement on the matter is now “overdue”.

In his paper, published in the International Journal of Astrobiology this month, Professor Wickramasinghe assesses the case that life had a cosmic origin in the light of astronomical discoveries of the past 30 years.

He argues that shows and organic dust are available on a huge scale, with a third of interstellar carbon in this form. He claims it is likely that a large amount of this material comes from decayed biological organisms, as is the case on Earth.

Professor Wickramasinghe concludes that the evidence of the past 30 years strengthens the case that life first came to Earth from impacting comets carrying around 3.8bn years ago.

However he argues that “cultural barriers” still exist to admitting the connection. In the paper, he says: “As we enter a new decade - the year 2010 - a clear pronouncement of our likely alien and of the existence of extraterrestrial life on a cosmic scale would seem to be overdue.”

More information: International Journal of Astrobiology: http://journals.ca … rnal?jid=IJA

Provided by Cardiff University (news : web)

3.7 /5 (20 votes)  

Filter


Move the slider to adjust rank threshold, so that you can hide some of the comments.


Display comments: newest first

RoboticExplorer
Feb 03, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (1)
An objective observer would tend to agree with this theory based on the evidence, unfortunately ~95 percent of the world population is not "objective" on matters pertaining to the origin of life.

This also begs the question "If it happened here, why not somewhere else with similar conditions?"
TegiriNenashi
Feb 03, 2010

Rank: 2 / 5 (4)
To prove his hypothesis he just has to sample some comet and witness some DNA content. Did he complete that?
GrayMouser
Feb 03, 2010

Rank: 3.7 / 5 (3)
Professor Wickramasinghe concludes that the evidence of the past 30 years strengthens the case that life first came to Earth from impacting comets carrying organic matter around 3.8bn years ago.

Probability & feelings don't prove anything. We certainly don't need any more "clear pronouncements" based on an artificial consensus.
RoboticExplorer
Feb 03, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (1)
To prove his hypothesis he just has to sample some comet and witness some DNA content. Did he complete that?


@TegiriNenashi: Organic matter, amino acids, and the like are the stuff complex life originated from. The theory does not state that preformed complex life like DNA crashed to earth and began life but instead implies, based off of the abundance of organic matter detected in Galaxy, that these building blocks of for life did and that our ideal environment allowed for growth and the evolution of life.

So no, your suggestion for proving his hypothesis is completely baseless and invalid. However I am sure anyone in support of this theory would love for NASA to send a probe to a comet to look for the building blocks of life....not alien, non-earth origin, DNA.
Skeptic_Heretic
Feb 04, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
In order for the hypothesis of this paper to be accurate the author would have to eliminate the possibility of Organic matter being formed terrestrially. He can't do it. Therefore the hypothesis is flawed.

Prior experiments have shown that the conditions on early earth, in addition to the processes related to aqueous volcanism both can lead to the known elements involved in the assemby of life. The "mounting evidence" is only evidence of yet another method by which life could have arisen.

It shows selective bias to state that there is only a single way in which life could have come about.
Drake411
Feb 04, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
Intact fossils found in a meteorite would sway me from my cultural bias and part me from my 45 bucks.
Rank 3.7 /5 (20 votes)
Related Stories
Relevant PhysicsForums posts
  • Titan's lack of impact craters
    created7 hours ago
  • Real pictures of black hole eating a star?
    createdFeb 08, 2012
  • Hypothetical way to travel faster than light, but not technically exceed lightspeed
    createdFeb 06, 2012
  • How do scientists monitor the Sun's activity?
    createdFeb 05, 2012
  • Search patterns in observational studies
    createdFeb 05, 2012
  • Derivation of Pogson's law
    createdFeb 03, 2012
  • More from Physics Forums - General Astronomy

More news stories

NASA's TRMM satellite sees Cyclone Jasmine in 3-D

Data from NASA's TRMM satellite was used to create a 3-Dimensional look at Cyclone Jasmine, currently moving through the South Pacific Ocean.

Space & Earth / Earth Sciences

created 1 hour ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0

Deconstructing a mystery: What caused Snowmaggedon?

In the quiet after the storms, streets and cars had all but disappeared under piles of snow. The U.S. Postal Service suspended service for the first time in 30 years. Snow plows struggled to push the evidence ...

Space & Earth / Earth Sciences

created 3 hours ago | popularity 4.5 / 5 (2) | comments 0 | with audio podcast

Researchers create 3-D laser maps that show how earthquake changes landscape

Geologists have a new tool to study how earthquakes change the landscape down to a few inches, and it's giving them insight into how earthquake faults behave. In the Feb. 10 issue of the journal Science, a team ...

Space & Earth / Earth Sciences

created 5 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (2) | comments 0 | with audio podcast

Ocean microbe communities changing, but long-term environmental impact is unclear

As oceans warm due to climate change, water layers will mix less and affect the microbes and plankton that pump carbon out of the atmosphere – but researchers say it's still unclear whether these processes ...

Space & Earth / Earth Sciences

created 5 hours ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0 | with audio podcast

NASA sees Tropical Storm 12S - a possible threat to Madagascar

The twelfth tropical depression formed in the Southern Indian Ocean today and quickly became a tropical storm, dubbed Tropical Storm 12S. NASA's Aqua satellite passed over the storm and captured infrared data that revealed ...

Space & Earth / Earth Sciences

created 3 hours ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0


Cannabis use doubles chances of vehicle crash

Drivers who consume cannabis within three hours of driving are nearly twice as likely to cause a vehicle collision as those who are not under the influence of drugs or alcohol claims a paper published today in the British ...

Study says children of women exposed to chemotherapy in pregnancy develop as well as other children

A study published Online First by The Lancet Oncology, and linked to The Lancet Series on cancer in pregnancy, shows that children of women exposed to chemotherapy while pregnant develop as well as children in the genera ...

Focus on self-improvement, rather than winning, benefits young athletes

Underserved youth athletes report more life skill and character development when their coaches place greater emphasis on creating caring climates instead of focusing on competition, according to research from ...

Current trend is to preserve pregnancy in patients diagnosed with cervical or ovarian cancer

The first paper in The Lancet Series on cancer in pregnancy explores the issues around gynaecological cancers, with cervical and ovarian being the most common. The current trend is to preserve pregnancy wherever possible. The fi ...

Surgery and chemotherapy are possible for pregnant women with breast cancer

Breast cancer in pregnant women is as common as in non-pregnant women of the same age, with no evidence to suggest pregnancy increases the risk of such cancer. In the majority of cases, pregnant women can have their breast ...

Complications of blood cancers make termination advisable at early stages of pregnancy

Lymphoma is the fourth most common cancer in pregnancy, affecting one in 6000 pregnancies. Non-Hodgkin lymphoma, acute leukaemia, and other blood cancers, while also rare, can also occur in pregnancy. The need for urgent ...