Dolphin cognitive abilities raise ethical questions, says Emory neuroscientist

February 18, 2010
Dolphin cognitive abilities raise ethical questions, says Emory neuroscientist

Two bottlenose dolphins playing with a bubble ring they just created. Photo by Brenda McCowan.

Many modern dolphin brains are significantly larger than those of humans and second in mass to the human brain when corrected for body size, says an Emory scientist. Some dolphin brains exhibit features correlated with complex intelligence, including a large expanse of neocortical volume that is more convoluted than that of humans, extensive insular and cingulated regions, and highly differentiated cellular regions. This has ethical and policy considerations.

Emory University neuroscientist Lori Marino will speak on the anatomical basis of dolphin at the American Association for the Advancement of Science conference (AAAS) in San Diego, on Sunday, Feb. 21.

"Many modern dolphin brains are significantly larger than our own and second in mass to the human when corrected for body size," Marino says.

A leading expert in the neuroanatomy of dolphins and whales, Marino will appear as part of a panel discussing these findings and their ethical and policy implications.

Some dolphin brains exhibit features correlated with complex intelligence, she says, including a large expanse of neocortical volume that is more convoluted than our own, extensive insular and cingulated regions, and highly differentiated cellular regions.

"Dolphins are sophisticated, self-aware, highly intelligent beings with individual personalities, autonomy and an inner life. They are vulnerable to tremendous suffering and ," Marino says.

The growing industry of capturing and confining dolphins to perform in marine parks or to swim with tourists at resorts needs to be reconsidered, she says.

"Our current knowledge of dolphin brain complexity and intelligence suggests that these practices are potentially psychologically harmful to dolphins and present a misinformed picture of their natural intellectual capacities," Marino says.

Marino worked on a 2001 study that showed that can recognize themselves in a mirror - a finding that indicates self-awareness similar to that seen in higher primates and elephants.

Provided by Emory University (news : web)

3.9 /5 (9 votes)  

Filter


Move the slider to adjust rank threshold, so that you can hide some of the comments.


Display comments: newest first

Lokheed
Feb 18, 2010

Rank: 1.7 / 5 (6)
Oh brother, not Marino again. Still trying to show that Dolphin's are humans? Please...

The simple fact is they are able to be trained. They are also done so through incentive and reward, not punishment. Firstly, it seems unlikely they are suffering, seeing as they are kept safe and plenty fat.

Secondly, while their intelligence is certainly surprising, it is no better than that of a primate. It is certainly not up to the level of a human. Moreover, brain size tells us nothing. When measured, pound for pound, the common shrew has the largest brain to body ratio. Surely, it's not the smartest animal alive...

Marino has a long history of producing research that makes strenuous and questionable inferences.
mauinut
Feb 19, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
an odd factoid; in the early sixties John C. Lilly(the pioneer of cetacean science/interspecies communication, owhile observing a group of captive dolphins, he noticed one that was exhibiting antisocial behaviors and not behaving like the others he got the wild idea of injecting 1000 mics of pure LSD into the dolphin and surprizingly enough the dolophins behavior became calm and social(normal by dolphin standards through the duration of the trip and when the dope wore off the animal returned to it's original behavior! nothing to do with the article just thought you all might like this. all of Dr. Lilly's books are quite interesting albeit a little much at times, but if cetations fascinate you, you should read some of his material!

Negative
Feb 19, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (1)
dear mr lokheed, everything in your discourse suggests a close relationship with the us army. the nick, the poor mastering of language and grammar, the blunt opinions about some animals that are, after all, excellent mine carriers...

and now this marino woman again!

chill.
GillesV
Feb 19, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (1)
Seems they're not trying to say they are humans, just that their intellect and self-awareness should bring us to question their internment for our entertainment. Even if they aren't as intelligent as us, if it makes them suffer, it has to stop since it's not necessary.

It is typical human arrogance to think we are superior enough not to have to ponder the way we treat other sentient beings...
baudrunner
Feb 19, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
It is not improbable that dolphins are smarter than a lot of, if not most humans. We keep them captive to satisfy our own curiosity of them, and they tolerate this because they are just as curious about us. In many ways we demonstrate a very primitive behaviour, even though we may be using tools to do so. It is wrong to judge a creature's intelligence from within the context of our own being.
MikeMike
Feb 19, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (1)
If any extraterrestrials monitor this forum please ignore Lokheed's comments. And bring nice toys if you can...
PinkElephant
Feb 19, 2010

Rank: 4 / 5 (2)
We keep them captive to satisfy our own curiosity of them, and they tolerate this because they are just as curious about us.

That's a very Douglas Adams kind of sentiment. Made me smile.

The big grains of cetaceans are employed in echolocation, navigation, and coordination of activities within a "school" of animals. Through sonar, they have high-fidelity volumetric "vision", in addition to their optical vision; this requires a great deal of additional brain matter to process and represent.

Lacking articulated appendages, and consigned to a relatively monotonous environment (compared to land), cetacean cognitive abilities are not so much geared toward tool use or invention, as is the case with the human brain.

So, while they are indeed quite intelligent, and social, the quality of their intellect is rather different and in some ways limited. I wouldn't go so far as to compare them to humans; I'm much more comfortable with an analogy to chimps.
KB6
Feb 19, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (2)
If we have no compelling need to make them suffer then we shouldn't, if for no other reason than our own intellectual and psychological integrity. It is not a complicated "moral" calculation.
And Lokheed: There's more to life, including a dolphin's life, than being safe and fat.
gwrede
Feb 20, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
I'd prefer that the American soldier in Afghanistan or Iraq, serving there against his own will, should be freed first.

But I do agree that animal suffering should be avoided.

However, dolphins performing at a sea world don't necessarily suffer. If their trainer loves them (instead of being a whip wielding dictator), and if they are given a sense of purpose and joy, the dolphins may well be as happy as those roaming some boring patch of coastal waters.
RubberBaron
Feb 21, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
Dolphins aren't just getting fat in cuddly sea worlds: http://www.4us2be...masacre/
Mercury_01
Feb 21, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
an interesting anecdote: My blood ancestors, the Juaneno of southern cal, regarded dolphins as the "spiritual people" of the sea. They as well as the aborigines of Australia have professed to be able to communicate with them through telepathy. Another strange one for you: I once visited the shedd aquarium in Chicago and saw a beluga there. It picked me out of the crowd as I walked by and followed me, looking directly at me for a few minutes, and as it did so, it let out a series of high pitched shrieks. Ive never had a headache before from any kind of noise, but when that whale opened it's mouth, I suddenly had the strangest tight feeling in my frontal lobes that I could not explain, followed by a lingering headache. Ive since wanted to go back to see if he would do it again. It was definitely an unusual experience, and I was left with the distinct feeling of having formally met this whale, almost like a human acquaintance.
Rank 3.9 /5 (9 votes)
Related Stories
Relevant PhysicsForums posts
  • Protease cleavage
    created7 hours ago
  • Pertubance in a model
    created13 hours ago
  • Cancer drugs and Alzheimer's, Oh my!
    created21 hours ago
  • Squishing cells
    created22 hours ago
  • Any books/articles for evolutionary stable strategy models in humans?
    createdFeb 09, 2012
  • Science behind the bore feeling?
    createdFeb 09, 2012
  • More from Physics Forums - Biology

More news stories

The power of estrogen -- male snakes attract other males

A new study has shown that boosting the estrogen levels of male garter snakes causes them to secrete the same pheromones that females use to attract suitors, and turned the males into just about the sexiest ...

Biology / Plants & Animals

created 11 hours ago | popularity 4.8 / 5 (5) | comments 0 | with audio podcast

Grass to gas: Researchers' genome map speeds biofuel development

Researchers at the University of Georgia have taken a major step in the ongoing effort to find sources of cleaner, renewable energy by mapping the genomes of two originator cells of Miscanthus x giganteus, a large perenn ...

Biology / Biotechnology

created 8 hours ago | popularity 3.8 / 5 (5) | comments 0 | with audio podcast

Experts reveal how plants don't get sunburn

(PhysOrg.com) -- Experts at the University of Glasgow have discovered how plants survive the harmful rays of the sun.

Biology / Cell & Microbiology

created 11 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (2) | comments 0 | with audio podcast

Miami battling invasion of giant African snails

No one knows how they got there. But an invasion of African giant snails has southern Florida in a panic over potential crop damage, disease and general yuckiness surrounding the slimy gastropods.

Biology / Ecology

created 15 hours ago | popularity 4 / 5 (1) | comments 4

Protein libraries in a snap

(PhysOrg.com) -- A Rice University undergraduate will depart with not only a degree but also a possible patent for his invention of an efficient way to create protein libraries, an important component of biomolecular ...

Biology / Cell & Microbiology

created 15 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (3) | comments 0 | with audio podcast


Google users warned of threat to smartphone wallets

Users of Google smartphone wallets were being warned on Friday that there is a way to crack pass codes intended to thwart thieves from going on illicit shopping sprees.

Anonymous knocks CIA website offline (Update)

The website of the Central Intelligence Agency was inaccessible on Friday after the hacker group Anonymous claimed to have knocked it offline.

Complex wiring of the nervous system may rely on a just a handful of genes and proteins

Researchers at the Salk Institute have discovered a startling feature of early brain development that helps to explain how complex neuron wiring patterns are programmed using just a handful of critical genes. ...

New error-correcting codes guarantee the fastest possible rate of data transmission

Error-correcting codes are one of the triumphs of the digital age. They’re a way of encoding information so that it can be transmitted across a communication channel — such as an optical fiber o ...

Putting the squeeze on planets outside our solar system

(PhysOrg.com) -- Using high-powered lasers, scientists at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory and collaborators discovered that molten magnesium silicate undergoes a phase change in the liquid state, abruptly ...

Humans may have helped the decline of African rainforests 3000 years ago

(PhysOrg.com) -- Large areas of rainforests in Central Africa mysteriously disappeared over three thousand years ago, to be replaced by savannas. The prevailing theory has been that the cause was a change ...