Rumblings about CERN is empty talk

March 16, 2010
Rumblings about CERN is empty talk

'Hadron Collider to be closed amid fears of a very big bang' read the headline in a major English newspaper and sparked controversy over the future of CERN. Was there a future for the large European research center?

”It is a controversy that has partially been created by a document sent out by the General Director of CERN, Rolf Heuer, and which was quoted incorrectly in a sensationalist headline. In the article itself, you can easily see that it is only talking about taking a limited break”, explain particle physicist at the Niels Bohr Institute, Hans Bøggild, who is the Danish member CERN’s scientific council.

Half power - half price

The fact is that the giant particle accelerator, the LHC, is going to be shut down for a period of six months to a year, but that won’t happen until 2012 and has been the plan since a meeting in January, when it was also decided that during the next two years the accelerator will ‘only’ run at energies that are half of the maximum energies the particle accelerator is capable of. This is being done because a longer break is required to make the machine ready for the next big jump in energy levels, so absolutely no chances for an accident are being taken.

”Some countries think that they should only have to pay half of their contingent for membership of CERN”, says Hans Bøggild, explaining that in England there been cuts in the budget of the scientific research council, so they are trying to find a reason to reduce the payment.

Dispute over money

The reason is that five countries are seeking to become members of CERN, which currently has 20 (soon to be 21) member countries. These are Cyprus, Turkey, Serbia, Slovenia and Israel and the scientific council will be discussing the decision later this month. If the new countries join there will also be new revenue and while some countries think that the money should be used to improve the scientific research opportunities, there are countries with hard-pressed economies who think that the extra funds should be used to reduce the contingent.

Whether the decision goes one way or the other, the winner is entirely up to the members of ’s scientific council (as representatives of the member countries). There is an important meeting later in the month. ”And it is a fight that has burst out into the open”, explains Hans Bøggild.

Groundbreaking discoveries

The LHC accelerator has been started up again after several months of the winter closure and in a month will run for the first time at energies of 7 TeV, which is a new and incredibly exciting energy area.

”It is the world’s most powerful and the potential is fantastic”, explains Hans Bøggild and adds that the experiments during the next two years could result in groundbreaking new scientific discoveries such as super symmetry, the universe’s mysterious dark matter and the Higgs particle - the missing piece in the puzzle of nature, the so-called Standard Model.

Provided by Niels Bohr Institute

3.8 /5 (6 votes)  

Filter


Move the slider to adjust rank threshold, so that you can hide some of the comments.


Display comments: newest first

JayK
Mar 17, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (1)
So you have that all on Copy/Paste ready for the next CERN thread?

And I thought I told you to stop wasting time and get out there with your sign and protest! Why are you still here?
Paradox
Mar 17, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (1)
Doc: I foresee two possibilities. One, coming face to face with herself 30 years older would put her into shock and she'd simply pass out. Or two, the encounter could create a time paradox, the results of which could cause a chain reaction that would unravel the very fabric of the space time continuum, and destroy the entire universe! Granted, that's a worse case scenario. The destruction might in fact be very localized, limited to merely our own galaxy.
Marty: Well, that's a relief.
seneca
Mar 17, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (4)
The destruction might in fact be very localized, limited to merely our own galaxy.

In the best case it might be localized just to CERN itself, but my question rather is, which evidence is required for LHC proponents for to consider such risk seriously. What all these expensive theories are good for, if physicists would simply ignore them anyway? Are we really predestined to check all possible variants, before choosing some safe one?
ubavontuba
Mar 17, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
Here's a fun paper by Steven B. Giddings (no less!) where he happily and repeatedly describes throwing the earth into a black hole!

http://cdsweb.cer...8151.pdf
daywalk3r
Mar 18, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (4)
Are we really predestined to check all possible variants, before choosing some safe one?
Are we really predestined to do nothing just because there is an almost infinite amount of possible outcomes for any possible action we could take?

"Hold your farts! There's a possibility that they could cause a hurricane to form on the other side of the globe, endangering thousands of human lives!" :-O

Does it mean that farting is bad? :-(
seneca
Mar 18, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (4)
If so, why not to place nuclear reactors in every family? E. Fermi has proven already, such reactor can be runned safely at open space in 1942 w/out problem. Why toxic substances and bacterial cultures aren't publicly available? They're all pretty safe under proper handling. Why to care about some security certificates and atestations at all?

http://en.wikiped...rinciple

The precautionary principle states that if an action or policy has suspected risk of causing harm to the public or to the environment, in the absence of a scientific consensus that harm would not ensue, the burden of proof falls on those who would advocate taking the action. In some legal systems, as in the law of the European Union, the application of the precautionary principle has been made a statutory requirement.

Does LHC follow the precautionary principle, after then?
JayK
Mar 18, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (1)
Did you lose your sign, seneca? Do we need to start a fund to buy you a new one so you can get back out there and picket?
broglia
Mar 19, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (1)
New amazing unforeseen radiation electron (beta) radiation leaking from the LHC that developed as the collider runs to deficiencies in the pre-accelerators including Electron Cloud trouble, and aging equipment and a need for higher energy injection beams with more bunches per beam or Billions More Dollars in upgrades. After Steve Meyers overview of radiation hazards developing and damaging equipment, to answer the big unspoken question hanging in the air, Meyers said: "I think a declaration 10 or 15 years ago that the underground service areas in the LHC were non-radiation areas." Maybe some unknown particles are escaping from beam while spreading radiation, as was observed already during Tevatron runs at Fermilab. During these collisions the formation of unstable heavy muon pairs was observed outside of collider pipe at unexpected distance from accelerator.

http://physicswor...ws/36514
broglia
Mar 19, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (2)
Today, an international group of critics and experts filed a complaint at the HRC at Geneva concerning risks and dangers of the planned experiments at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) operated by the CERN in Switzerland.

http://lhc-concer...onal.pdf

Please take a closer look at this important paper including a detailed physical part describing the scientific discourse but also having a general and very profound approach to the topic with clear suggestions to improve safety and to urgently set new standards in high energy particle collider risk evaluation.

Request to CERN Council and Member States on LHC

http://lhc-concer...2010.pdf
in7x
Mar 19, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (2)
The biggest problem is that this has been the most hyped particle experiment ever.

If you were to ask your average frothy protester about the SLAC or RHIC and how they compare to the energy levels and dangers of the LHC they'd stare at you blankly.

Throw out a science fiction term like "black hole" and "possibility" and suddenly everyone's ready to save the whales.

Hey, at least they're interested in particle physics - I guess.
broglia
Mar 19, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (2)
If you were to ask your average frothy protester about the SLAC or RHIC and how they compare to the energy levels and dangers of the LHC they'd stare at you blankly.
Why do you think so? Many evidences of LHC risk were observed already at Tevatron or RHIC: dimuon events, penta-quark observation, jet suppression, i.e. black hole formation, etc.

http://news.bbc.c...7613.stm

Physicist know quite well, they're close to critical point already.

http://cdsweb.cer...7165.pdf
in7x
Mar 19, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (4)
Thanks for the links, broglia.

But lets be clear: "striking similarity to" does not equal "is" a black hole.

Have there been any follow-ups to this five year old article?

There's large leaps from mathematical abstraction and "lore" to world-ending-events.

From your article: "Ten times as many jets were being absorbed by the fireball as were predicted by calculations."

Yet unwavering confidence can be maintained in the number crunching?

And if black holes ARE plasma[fire]balls, then what does that mean for the plasma cosmology deniers?

Until string theory is verified, how authors can flip and flop between GR and QM as if one supports the other? I thought that was the root of our troubles?

There are just so many loose ends, how some people can grab their holy books and start shouting "REPENT!" seems truly fantastic.

But hey, personally, I wouldn't mind seeing black hole creation, formation, and verification if for nothing else but science sake. Why fight progress?
Chef
Mar 20, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
"but that won’t happen until 2012"

The restart wouldn't happen to be Dec 21st, 2012, would it?
seneca
Mar 20, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (1)
..personally, I wouldn't mind seeing black hole creation, formation, and verification if for nothing else but science sake. Why fight progress?
Progress is in observation of these things in safe and effective way. Until we have no usage for it, it's as questionable progress, like the sudden observation of clouds at Pluto planet. I'd rather call it a waste of money, which could be spend somewhere else, instead.
frajo
Mar 21, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
"but that won't happen until 2012"

The restart wouldn't happen to be Dec 21st, 2012, would it?


I really would like to know what's so special about this date. Why do you mention this date?

I hope I don't break any taboo by raising this question.
If yes, it is unknowingly and I beg all people I might have hurt to pardon me.
otto1923
Mar 21, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
12/21/12
End of Mayan calendar
end of grand cycle
end of world?
frajo
Mar 24, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (2)
12/21/12
End of Mayan calendar
end of grand cycle
end of world?
Thanks for explaining.

Superstition is older and stronger than any religion; it is the formless slime-like tissue of religion.
Slotin
Mar 28, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (2)
But the belief, LHC cannot harm the people is a pure superstition, too. Such "arguments" are completelly symmetrical and therefore irrelevant here.
Skeptic_Heretic
Apr 02, 2010

Rank: 3 / 5 (2)
12/21/12
End of Mayan calendar
end of grand cycle
end of world?

My desk calendar ends on 12/31/2010. Does that mean the world is ending or should I simply carve/buy a new one?
Rank 3.8 /5 (6 votes)
Related Stories
Relevant PhysicsForums posts
  • Dark Energy question
    created43 minutes ago
  • Wind Turbine Power
    created2 hours ago
  • Steam Table issues
    created4 hours ago
  • electrostatic induction in a conductor should be immpossible
    created8 hours ago
  • Help! Physics Momentum/Impulse problem!
    created11 hours ago
  • Gauss' law cubes, how to prove
    created12 hours ago
  • More from Physics Forums - General Physics

More news stories

SLAC, Stanford team focuses on high-energy electrons to treat cancer

Accelerator physicists at SLAC and cancer specialists from Stanford are working on a new technology that could dramatically reduce the time needed for cancer radiation treatments. The team ran an initial experiment ...

Physics / General Physics

created 2 hours ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0

Measurements from high-energy collisions lead to better understanding of why meson particles disappear

For several years, physicists at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) at Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL), USA, have studied an unusual state of matter called the quark–gluon plasma, which they ...

Physics / General Physics

created 2 hours ago | popularity not rated yet | comments 0

Quantum physicist explains $100K offer for proof scaled-up quantum computing is impossible

(PhysOrg.com) -- MIT researcher Scott Aaronson has certainly riled the physics community with his offer this past Friday, of $100,000 to anyone who can prove that scaled-up quantum computing is impossible. ...

Physics / Quantum Physics

created Feb 08, 2012 | popularity 4.1 / 5 (11) | comments 32 | with audio podcast weblog

Explained: Sigma

It's a question that arises with virtually every major new finding in science or medicine: What makes a result reliable enough to be taken seriously? The answer has to do with statistical significance -- but ...

Physics / General Physics

created Feb 09, 2012 | popularity 5 / 5 (13) | comments 26

Physicists 'record' magnetic breakthrough

An international team of scientists has demonstrated a revolutionary new way of magnetic recording which will allow information to be processed hundreds of times faster than by current hard drive technology.

Physics / General Physics

created Feb 07, 2012 | popularity 4.5 / 5 (39) | comments 14 | with audio podcast


Netflix light on flicks as viewers soak up TV shows

Like most fresh faces that arrive in Hollywood, Netflix wanted to be a movie star. But now it's learning what many in Tinseltown have known for decades: Movies are sexy, but the real money is in television.

Antidepressants and pregnancy: Women must consider the impact of drugs on baby, and of depression on baby, themselves

Upon learning they are pregnant, most women dutifully nix the alcohol, sushi and caffeine. But what about antidepressants?

Curry spice component may help slow prostate tumor growth

Curcumin, an active component of the Indian curry spice turmeric, may help slow down tumor growth in castration-resistant prostate cancer patients on androgen deprivation therapy (ADT), a study from researchers ...

The power of estrogen -- male snakes attract other males

A new study has shown that boosting the estrogen levels of male garter snakes causes them to secrete the same pheromones that females use to attract suitors, and turned the males into just about the sexiest ...

Humans may have helped the decline of African rainforests 3000 years ago

(PhysOrg.com) -- Large areas of rainforests in Central Africa mysteriously disappeared over three thousand years ago, to be replaced by savannas. The prevailing theory has been that the cause was a change ...

Fool's gold may prove an unlikely alternative to overexploited catalytic materials

Catalytic materials, which lower the energy barriers for chemical reactions, are used in everything from the commercial production of chemicals to catalytic converters in car engines. However, with current catalytic materials ...