'Starving yogi' astounds Indian scientists

May 10, 2010 by Rajesh Joshi
Prahlad Jani spent a fortnight in a hospital in Gujarat under constant surveillance from medics

Enlarge

Indian holy man Prahlad Jani speaks at a press conference at a hospital in Ahmedbad on May 6. Jani, who says he has spent seven decades without food or water, has astounded a team of military doctors who studied him during a two-week observation period.

An 83-year-old Indian holy man who says he has spent seven decades without food or water has astounded a team of military doctors who studied him during a two-week observation period.

Prahlad Jani spent a fortnight in a hospital in the western India state of Gujarat under constant surveillance from a team of 30 medics equipped with cameras and closed circuit television.

During the period, he neither ate nor drank and did not go to the toilet.

"We still do not know how he survives," neurologist Sudhir Shah told reporters after the end of the experiment. "It is still a mystery what kind of phenomenon this is."

The long-haired and bearded yogi was sealed in a hospital in the city of Ahmedabad in a study initiated by India's Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO), the state defence and military research institute.

The DRDO hopes that the findings, set to be released in greater detail in several months, could help soldiers survive without food and drink, assist astronauts or even save the lives of people trapped in natural disasters.

"(Jani's) only contact with any kind of fluid was during gargling and bathing periodically during the period," G. Ilavazahagan, director of India's Defence Institute of Physiology and Allied Sciences (DIPAS), said in a statement.

Jani has since returned to his village near Ambaji in northern Gujarat where he will resume his routine of yoga and meditation. He says that he was blessed by a goddess at a young age, which gave him special powers.

During the 15-day observation, which ended on Thursday, the doctors took scans of Jani's organs, brain, and blood vessels, as well as doing tests on his heart, lungs and memory capacity.

"The reports were all in the pre-determined safety range through the observation period," Shah told reporters at a press conference last week.

Other results from , molecular biological studies and tests on his hormones, enzymes, and genes will take months to come through.

"If Jani does not derive energy from food and water, he must be doing that from energy sources around him, sunlight being one," said Shah.

"As medical practitioners we cannot shut our eyes to possibilities, to a source of energy other than calories."

(c) 2010 AFP

4.3 /5 (68 votes)  

Filter


Move the slider to adjust rank threshold, so that you can hide some of the comments.


Display comments: newest first

smoke_and_mirrors
May 10, 2010

Rank: 4.4 / 5 (14)
Is it just because he's smarter than the average bear?

Sorry - something does not ring true about this. The last sentence is very suspicious. I remember the laughable debacle of Jasmuheen - who also claimed to "live on light". She was caught pigging out on an aeroplane, lol. Or at least it would be funny were anorexia not such a hideous problem.
Hunnter
May 10, 2010

Rank: 1.4 / 5 (7)
Damn, meant to hit 5, anyway, yeah, something tells me he might just be smart at concealing things.
Maybe he has found some sort of super food which he conceals in his mouth or something along those lines.

Either that or he really is genetically fairly unique.
Living on light, or EM in general isn't out of the realm of possibility, we know of many lifeforms that depend on EM for energy.
And given a fairly static life without too much pressure and stress, a person probably wouldn't need to regenerate much of the molecules in his body, as long as they didn't make a habit of losing skin or hair everything else should be contained if he isn't going to the loo.

Or he was "blessed".

Certainly worth looking in to, especially considering those 2 weeks.
He is either really smart, or really unique.
Both will provide insight.
Ravenrant
May 10, 2010

Rank: 4.1 / 5 (7)
He needs to be observed in a closed environment for more than 2 weeks to determine if he can survive without anything. He may be getting sustenance from something in his normal environment that isn't in a closed environment and 2 weeks isn't enough to tell. He may not even know what it is. People have survived longer than that on nothing, 2 weeks doesn't prove anything.
JJC
May 10, 2010

Rank: 3.5 / 5 (8)
Assuming he swallowed a little bit of water while bathing and gargling, and spent almost all of his time in meditation or non-stressful yoga poses, the answer may just be that he uses little energy.

Not to say this isn't amazing. Certainly it is.
visual
May 10, 2010

Rank: 4.6 / 5 (9)
It's not just a matter of how he gets energy, but also mass as well.
He lost weight the last time he was under documented observation like this, I think it was for 10 days or such.
Probably it was the same this time around, only the article lack any actual details.

He clearly can't regain that weight just from the sunlight. He is a scammer.
Sinister181
May 10, 2010

Rank: 3.8 / 5 (10)
Personally, I think something here sounds like a hoax. The article isn't too extensive either. Maybe he eats, drinks, and poops in private. Either that, or disables the surveillance systems somehow. There's no way someone can survive on air alone. I wonder which Goddess "blessed" him.
LariAnn
May 10, 2010

Rank: 3.1 / 5 (12)
You know, it wasn't too long ago that reports of people living to over 100 years old were also pooh-poohed as hoaxes. While prosaic explanations cannot be ruled out entirely without further study, can't people admit that they don't know everything? Without an unanswered question, there will be no scientific study!
Djincs
May 10, 2010

Rank: 2.7 / 5 (7)
15 days , come on and this garglin, he has a long beard you cant see is he swallow a little bit each time, with shure he is a lier....
NameIsNotNick
May 10, 2010

Rank: 3.8 / 5 (10)
You know, it wasn't too long ago that reports of people living to over 100 years old were also pooh-poohed as hoaxes. While prosaic explanations cannot be ruled out entirely without further study, can't people admit that they don't know everything? Without an unanswered question, there will be no scientific study!

These kind of claims have been made before and have always turned out to be hoaxes. Because we don't know everything doesn't mean we don't know anything. To paraphrase Marcello Truzzi: "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof".
Quantum_Conundrum
May 10, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (8)
You know, it wasn't too long ago that reports of people living to over 100 years old were also pooh-poohed as hoaxes.


Um...in the case of some of the "oldes person alive" claims, one woman verifiably has 90-something year old children and has independent paperwork from her confirmation via the Cahtolic Church which shows she was 134 years old.

As far as fasting, the Bible records SEVERAL 40+ day total fasts without food or water by Moses (literally at least twice in a row, or 80 days consecutively), Elijah(Implied, but unknown duration,) and Jesus, as well as several others having total or partial fasts of 7 to 21 days.

From a Christian perspective I believe that there is something supernatural about these events.

We also find several instances in the Bible where demonic activity gave people super-human strength, such as the ability to break metal chains, or to overcome a group of seven men in a fight.

Therefore I would classify this as a "lying wonder"
yyz
May 10, 2010

Rank: 4.2 / 5 (10)
It appears Jani may not have been alone in this deception. The wiki entry for 'inedia' includes a section on Jani( http://en.wikiped...lad_Jani )that states:

Sanal Edamaruku of the Indian Rationalist Association claimed to have been repeatedly denied sending an independent team to survey the room where Jani was held. He also claimed that "this particular hospital, led by this particular doctor, keeps on making these claims without ever producing evidence or publishing research."

Further reading of the entry only confirms that Jani and others making this claim are 'fakirs' and that some people have in fact starved to death trying to emulate these people.
Truth
May 10, 2010

Rank: 3.5 / 5 (11)
Well, I'm glad to see that we Americans are not the only ones who get routinely scammed by televangelists and other fairy tale hoodwinkers. Looks like bamboozling is a world-wide phenomena. Oh, don't forget to buy that $14.99 book about the end of the world and the rapture. On sale now!
dirk_bruere
May 10, 2010

Rank: 2.6 / 5 (5)
Going without food for 15 days is not a problem. But then again, maybe he cheated by eating his own foot?
paulthebassguy
May 11, 2010

Rank: 3.4 / 5 (5)
I also was blessed as a child and I have a similar amazing condition. You see, everything that I eat is turned directly into energy and provided I do enough physical exercise in a day I don't even need to poop. I haven't pooped for 25 years.

I am offering this opportunity to any scientists on here to study me - please contact me and we can make arrangements including a figure.
Skepticus
May 11, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (3)
From a scientific point of view, they should have put him in an isolation chamber to monitor all amounts of oxygen, co2, water vapor, infrared and other radiation emission and absorption, etc, to have a complete picture..and checking the amounts of water after mouth washes and bath, taking into account of normal loses. This way his supposed feat would be more rigorously tested.
PinkElephant
May 11, 2010

Rank: 4.6 / 5 (9)
I haven't pooped for 25 years.
Pardon my directness, but wouldn't that entail that you're incredibly full of sh*t by now? =P (j/k)

For some reason, I'm reminded of the Golgothan, from Dogma (the movie.) Maybe it's because of the way this yogi's story smells...
satyricon
May 11, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (2)
Unconscious binging in the dead of night? Maybe he has NS-RED? If they have observed him 24/7 for two weeks then this is something scientists should definitely probe further and give it massive attention.
MarkyMark
May 11, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (2)
I haven't pooped for 25 years.
Pardon my directness, but wouldn't that entail that you're incredibly full of sh*t by now? =P (j/k)

For some reason, I'm reminded of the Golgothan, from Dogma (the movie.) Maybe it's because of the way this yogi's story smells...

LoL that made me laugh. Perhaps he just chews the matress at night?
Anarch157a
May 11, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (2)
mohandas gandhi kept hunger strikes longer than that as protest, taking only water, lemon juice and some sugar during the protests.

as it was said before, with a long beard and hair, this guy could have concealed some sugar and used sleight of hand tricks to consume it during the time under observation.

magicians are known to be able to perform tricks that not even close inspection using cameras can show how they do it.

i call shenanigans on this yogi.
Djincs
May 11, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (1)
the trick is in gargling, no food ok(for two weeks), but no wather isnt ok...
freethinking
May 11, 2010

Rank: 1.8 / 5 (5)
I hate things like this because I need to agree with none other that Pink E. Get a magician to observe him and I bet within a very short time you will have this trick duplicated. I think that the scientist that observed him are of the same quality as the AGW scientists.

On a side note, and I think even PE would agree, televangilists who say they have cured people should be forced to prove they have done so. Medical reports before and after.

A person once said, a skeptic is the easiest person to make into a beliver. If they see something with their own eyes they believe. A free thinker sees something then finds out how it was done.
xstos
May 11, 2010

Rank: 1.7 / 5 (6)
"Where does it come from? This quest, this need to solve life's mysteries, when the simplest of questions can never be answered. Why are we here? What is the soul? Why do we dream? Perhaps we'd be better off not looking at all... not delving, not yearning. But that's not human nature. Not the human heart. That is not why we are here."

- Mohinder Suresh (Heroes)
MikeLisanke
May 12, 2010

Rank: 4.2 / 5 (5)
Why is science sponsored mysticism acceptable? Test him in a closed system; if he radiates energy (he does) and exhales H2O and CO2 (he does) and sweats H2O (he does) and assuming he obviously did not excrete excess protein imbalance, then he'll need to replenish them at the rate he emits these things. If he acquires nutrients and H2O from breathing, then he does this more efficiently then others and this too would be obvious in a closed system.
dsl5000
May 12, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (2)
Haha he has PIC line, of course he doesn't need to drink :) This article omits a lot of critical informations.
IngDutch
May 12, 2010

Rank: 3.4 / 5 (5)
http://www.youtub...6eJB9GLY

I'm just linking James Randi, because he just did a video on this topic. I love this website for its critical commenters. It seems allot of other websites the commenters have there head in the clouds.
GoodElf
May 13, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (8)
Assuming that this investigation by the military hospital is correct... it is possible that since human beings are 90% composed of organisms other than human cells, they might be providing him with a "closed ecosystem" in balance.
http://www.techno...0/page1/
He claims to be provided with some "fluid" from a hole in his palate. It may be he gets enough water from condensation inside his body from the atmosphere to compensate for water losses. The other organisms in his body may be providing him with all the internal sustenance he needs. It is just conceivable that some individuals have unique combination's of "flora and fauna" that are similar to "bottled ecosystems"... self sustaining and self limiting.
http://settlement.../ecosys/
Additional energy requirements may be provided by sunlight and conversion in the cells by our host mitochondria.

Similar stories of Sadu's being buried for months in the earth.
re_coyote
May 13, 2010

Rank: 1.8 / 5 (5)
wrong this guy was sent by the plants to teach us a lesson, the plants after enduring humanity for this long created this person for us
otto1923
May 13, 2010

Rank: 3.7 / 5 (3)
has astounded a team of military doctors
"All of war is deception." Sun Tsu

@paulthebassguy
-Please see new indie movie for ramifications of your affliction:
http://movies.nyt...man.html
thyran
May 15, 2010

Rank: 3.7 / 5 (3)
wrong this guy was sent by the plants to teach us a lesson, the plants after enduring humanity for this long created this person for us

Next to water and sunlight, plants need nutrients from their immediate surroundings as well.
thermodynamics
May 16, 2010

Rank: 2.5 / 5 (8)
I am astounded by the number of people commenting who even give a shred of credence to this article.
Eric_B
May 16, 2010

Rank: 3.3 / 5 (4)
"Similar stories of Sadu's being buried for months in the earth."
Buried in a pile of horsesh*t!
Eco_R1
May 17, 2010

Rank: 3 / 5 (2)
i love steak,chips,pizza and all the other stuff way to much to try and do this
Donna12283
May 17, 2010

Rank: 2.4 / 5 (5)
I heard about this guy many years ago when they did similar study on him. He's authentic. Westerners just can't open their minds to the FACT that many many yogi's live this way. Remember manna from above? Buddha lived that way too for many years.
weewilly
May 17, 2010

Rank: 3 / 5 (2)
I would keep an opened mind about this. No one understands everything and a scientific study can be done again to prove the validity of the first or second one. If it is a trick I sure would like to know how it is done.
Skepticus
May 18, 2010

Rank: 1 / 5 (1)
Oriental mysticism, scientific skepticism, religious and racial prejudice, out right emotional dismissal...is a potent mix. Fascinating, humans.
Raygunner
May 28, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
Got some munchies hidden in his beard I bet
Rank 4.3 /5 (68 votes)
Related Stories
Relevant PhysicsForums posts

More news stories

Discovery predicts patient sensitivity to important drug target in deadly brain cancer

A recent discovery by Van Andel Research Institute (VARI) scientists enables the prediction of patient sensitivity to proposed drug therapies for glioblastoma – the most common and most aggressive malignant brain tumor ...

Medicine & Health / Cancer

created 11 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (1) | comments 0 | with audio podcast

New study finds individual differences in anthrax susceptibility

Susceptibility to anthrax toxin is a heritable genetic trait that may vary tremendously among individuals, according to a new study by researchers at the Stanford University School of Medicine.

Medicine & Health / Genetics

created 12 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (1) | comments 0 | with audio podcast

Study identifies new prostate cancer drug target

Research led by Wanguo Liu, PhD, Associate Professor of Genetics at LSU Health Sciences Center New Orleans, has identified a new protein critical to the development and growth of prostate cancer. The findings are published ...

Medicine & Health / Cancer

created 12 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (1) | comments 0 | with audio podcast

Tasting fructose with the pancreas

Taste receptors on the tongue help us distinguish between safe food and food that's spoiled or toxic. But taste receptors are now being found in other organs, too. In a study published online the week of February ...

Medicine & Health / Research

created 12 hours ago | popularity 4.5 / 5 (6) | comments 0 | with audio podcast

Exercise triggers stem cells in muscle

University of Illinois researchers determined that an adult stem cell present in muscle is responsive to exercise, a discovery that may provide a link between exercise and muscle health. The findings could lead to new therapeutic ...

Medicine & Health / Research

created 14 hours ago | popularity 4.7 / 5 (6) | comments 0 | with audio podcast


Nicira promises virtual networks will transform networking

(PhysOrg.com) -- For the past four years, founders of the start-up company Nicira have been developing cutting-edge software that they predict will transform the networking technology underlying the Internet. ...

Navy to begin tests on electromagnetic railgun prototype launcher

The Office of Naval Research (ONR)'s Electromagnetic (EM) Railgun program will take an important step forward in the coming weeks when the first industry railgun prototype launcher is tested at a facility ...

Study of diving beetles suggest sperm evolution may be driven by changes in female reproductive organs

Studying female reproductive tracts and sperm in diving beetles (Dytiscidae), researchers from the University of Arizona and Syracuse University have obtained a glimpse into a bizarre and amazing world of spe ...

Fossil cricket: Jurassic love song reconstructed

Some 165 million years ago, the world was host to a diversity of sounds. Primitive bushcrickets and croaking amphibians were among the first animals to produce loud sounds by stridulation (rubbing certain body parts together). ...

New insight from whole-genome sequencing of Europe's 2011 E. coli outbreaks

Using whole-genome sequencing, a team led by researchers from Harvard School of Public Health (HSPH) and the Broad Institute has traced the path of the E. coli outbreak that sickened thousands and killed over 50 people in Ger ...

Redder ladybirds more deadly, say scientists

A ladybird's colour indicates how well-fed and how toxic it is, according to an international team of scientists. Research led by the Universities of Exeter and Liverpool directly shows that differences between ...