One high-fat diet, two different outcomes: The path to obesity becomes clearer

August 2, 2010

Why is it that two people can consume the same high fat, high-calorie Western diet and one becomes obese and prone to diabetes while the other maintains a slim frame? This question has long baffled scientists, but a study by Yale School of Medicine researchers provides a simple explanation: weight is set before birth in the developing brain.

The results are reported online the week of August 2 in the .

Led by Tamas Horvath, chair and professor of comparative medicine and professor of neurobiology and obstetrics & gynecology at Yale School of Medicine, the research team analyzed the same question in specific groups of rats. These animals have been bred so that their vulnerability to diet-induced obesity is known before they would be put on high-fat, high-calorie diet diets.

Horvath said animals that become obese already had a significant difference in the feeding center of the brain. Neurons that are supposed to signal when you've eaten enough and when to burn calories, are much more sluggish in these animals because they are inhibited by other cells. In animals resistant to obesity, these satiety signaling neurons are much more active and ready to signal to the rest of the brain and peripheral tissues when enough food has been consumed.

"It appears that this base wiring of the brain is a determinant of one's vulnerability to develop obesity," said Horvath, who is also co-director of the Yale Program in Integrative Cell Signaling and Neurobiology of Metabolism. "These observations add to the argument that it is less about personal will that makes a difference in becoming obese, and, it is more related to the connections that emerge in our brain during development."

Horvath points to other unwanted consequences of these brain mechanisms. "Those who are vulnerable to diet-induced obesity also develop a brain inflammation, while those who are resistant, do not," he said. "This emerging inflammatory response in the brain may also explain why those who once developed obesity have a harder time losing weight."

Diet-induced obesity has become one of the most critical medical problems in the United States. In particular, the incidence of childhood obesity has reached unprecedented levels. Since genetics alone cannot explain the surge of obesity in society, investigators have been trying to determine the primary underpinnings of the vulnerability to develop obesity on a Western diet.

"What genetic, epigenetic and environmental factor determines this base wiring in the brain is a very important issue to address," said Horvath. "Specifically, the emerging view is that besides genetics, maternal impact on the developing is likely to be critical to imprint these feeding circuits thereby determining one's vulnerability or resistance to ."

More information: Citation: PNAS doi:10.1073/pnas.1004282107

Provided by Yale University (news : web)

3.8 /5 (8 votes)  

Filter


Move the slider to adjust rank threshold, so that you can hide some of the comments.


Display comments: newest first

Trim
Aug 02, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (2)
Different brain states only partially explains overweight. I am overweight but I eat and drink less than plenty of thin blokes, they don't exercise much either. Having a more efficient or sluggish metabolism probably contributes as well.
AlejoHausner
Aug 02, 2010

Rank: 3 / 5 (3)
So it turns out that your brain is in charge of what you eat? That's very counter-intuitive, if you think about it.

Storing energy for future use is crucial, in a natural world where food is not always available. So nature has evolved many physiological (body-based) mechanisms to make sure you don't lose weight, to make sure the next famine doesn't wipe out the species. Why would the conscious brain, a very late arrival in the animal world, play any significant role in weight control?

Studies like this serve only to flatter our sense that we are in charge of our bodies.

Alejo Hausner
jamesrm
Aug 03, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (2)
"but I eat and drink less than plenty of thin blokes"

maybe should read
but I THINK I eat and drink less than plenty of thin blokes

http://www.bbc.co...hs.shtml
Often, overweight people believe they eat very little and still put on weight, hence the 'slow metabolism' theory, but research has shown people tend to eat more than they think.

rgds
james
Grallen
Aug 03, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (2)
"but I eat and drink less than plenty of thin blokes"

maybe should read
but I THINK I eat and drink less than plenty of thin blokes

http://www.bbc.co...hs.shtml
Often, overweight people believe they eat very little and still put on weight, hence the 'slow metabolism' theory, but research has shown people tend to eat more than they think.

rgds
james


It's true.

My roommate thought he ate the same as I did until I pointed out him taking seconds helpings, large portions, and having snacks where I didn't.

Also he had habits like where he would always have a desert with dinner because it didn't feel right without it.

He was actually consuming over twice as many calories while thinking he ate no more than me.
marjon
Aug 03, 2010

Rank: 3 / 5 (2)
Since genetics alone cannot explain the surge of obesity in society, investigators have been trying to determine the primary underpinnings of the vulnerability to develop obesity on a Western diet.

Human diet studies are even more uncertain than global climate. Few are willing to be test subjects for the months required. Different food types and quality have different effects. Fructose, sucrose and glucose are not metabolized the same way. Fats are all not created equal. Same for carbs and what about vitamin and mineral contents?
So far, what I have found that works best is to eat according to your genetic type. Eat the foods you were adapted to eat.
richgibula
Aug 03, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
Two things:
First, the start of the article talks about the same high fat diet and some people gaining more than others. That's different than choosing when to stop eating.
Second, when I tested the slow metabolism theory, I was backpacking for a week with my thin friends. Some ate up to 3 x the portions I did. That did not change my weight or theirs and helped to convince them that there was more to being overweight than just diet.
degojoey
Aug 03, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
im 27, 140 lbs, up from 130 lbs on a high calorie diet to gain weight. Im forcing 3500 calories in my body daily, forcing being the key word. Ive seen my fat friends eat 2000 calories in a single steak and shake sitting, easy.. Count your calories over a longer period of time, you will see that it IS your diet that determines your weight.
trekgeek1
Aug 03, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
"but I eat and drink less than plenty of thin blokes"

maybe should read
but I THINK I eat and drink less than plenty of thin blokes

http://www.bbc.co...hs.shtml
Often, overweight people believe they eat very little and still put on weight, hence the 'slow metabolism' theory, but research has shown people tend to eat more than they think.

rgds
james


Exactly what I was thinking. Five stars for you. I recall a show entitled "I eat 30,000 calories a day", or something along that number, where the man insisted he ate no more than a typical man. People can have slower metabolisms, but don't fool yourself into thinking it makes the difference between slim and obese. The differences are minute.
hbar_squared
Aug 03, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
How do the changes in pre-natal brains come about? It can't be purely genetic, because that wouldn't explain the sudden rise in childhood obesity. Does it relate to the mother's diet while pregnant?
Skeptic_Heretic
Aug 03, 2010

Rank: 5 / 5 (1)
There are ways you can eat less and gain weight.

If you skip breakfast but the rest of your diet remains the same, you will often put on weight.

I've been told this is because of the various chemical signatures that tell your body whether to burn or bank energy. I can't speak with any sort of authority, it's hearsay from long ago.
zenmom
Aug 09, 2010

Rank: not rated yet
I once read of a study where they had people keep a food diary for a week, then shut them up in a dormitory for a week and fed them exactly what they had recorded in their food diary. Boy, were those test subjects hungry by the end of the week!
Rank 3.8 /5 (8 votes)
Relevant PhysicsForums posts
  • Is Everyday Technology Killing Us?
    createdFeb 08, 2012
  • Exercise and weight loss
    createdFeb 08, 2012
  • Why do we have head aches? Our brains can't feel anything.
    createdFeb 07, 2012
  • "The end of diseases" by David Agus, interview from Daily Show with Jon Stewart
    createdFeb 04, 2012
  • Oncolytic adenovirus
    createdFeb 04, 2012
  • Nutrition label stuffs and diets
    createdFeb 02, 2012
  • More from Physics Forums - Medical Sciences

More news stories

Complex wiring of the nervous system may rely on a just a handful of genes and proteins

Researchers at the Salk Institute have discovered a startling feature of early brain development that helps to explain how complex neuron wiring patterns are programmed using just a handful of critical genes. ...

Medicine & Health / Research

created 14 hours ago | popularity 4.9 / 5 (9) | comments 1 | with audio podcast

Team isolates nerve cells involved in storing long term memory and gene proteins associated with them

(Medical Xpress) -- A research team in Taiwan has succeeded in isolating two nerve cells in fruit fly brains that are believed to be the major players in allowing for the formation of long term memories. Furthermore, ...

Medicine & Health / Neuroscience

created 20 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (4) | comments 2 | with audio podcast report

Seeing colors in music, tasting flavors in shapes may happen in life's early months

Famed violinist Itzhak Perlman sees a deep forest green whenever he plays a B-flat on his Stradivarius' G string. The A on the E string is red.

Medicine & Health / Psychology & Psychiatry

created 21 hours ago | popularity 4.5 / 5 (2) | comments 2 | with audio podcast

Both maternal and paternal age linked to autism

Older maternal and paternal age are jointly associated with having a child with autism, according to a recently published study led by researchers at The University of Texas Health Science Center at Houston (UTHealth).

Medicine & Health / Psychology & Psychiatry

created 18 hours ago | popularity 4.3 / 5 (3) | comments 0 | with audio podcast

New understanding of DNA repair could eventually lead to cancer therapy

A research group in the Faculty of Medicine & Dentistry at the University of Alberta is hoping its latest discovery could one day be used to develop new therapies that target certain types of cancers.

Medicine & Health / Cancer

created 18 hours ago | popularity 4.8 / 5 (6) | comments 0 | with audio podcast


Anonymous knocks CIA website offline (Update)

The website of the Central Intelligence Agency was inaccessible on Friday after the hacker group Anonymous claimed to have knocked it offline.

New error-correcting codes guarantee the fastest possible rate of data transmission

Error-correcting codes are one of the triumphs of the digital age. They’re a way of encoding information so that it can be transmitted across a communication channel — such as an optical fiber o ...

Small modular reactor design could be a 'SUPERSTAR'

(PhysOrg.com) -- Though most of today's nuclear reactors are cooled by water, we've long known that there are alternatives; in fact, the world's first nuclear-powered electricity in 1951 came from a reactor ...

New power source discovered

(PhysOrg.com) -- Researchers at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) and RMIT University have made a breakthrough in energy storage and power generation.

The power of estrogen -- male snakes attract other males

A new study has shown that boosting the estrogen levels of male garter snakes causes them to secrete the same pheromones that females use to attract suitors, and turned the males into just about the sexiest ...

Advanced power-grid model finds low-cost, low-carbon future in West

(PhysOrg.com) -- The least expensive way for the Western U.S. to reduce greenhouse gas emissions enough to help prevent the worst consequences of global warming is to replace coal with renewable and other ...